Best Elementary Schools in Bensonhurst
The top elementary schools in Bensonhurst, ranked by our overall rating — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. Success Academy Charter School - Bensonhurst leads with 95/100, followed by P.S. 247 Brooklyn and P.S. 205 Clarion. 14 elementary schools in Bensonhurst in total.
The ranking
1
Success Academy Charter School - Bensonhurst99 AVENUE P
- K–5 Elementary
2
P.S. 247 Brooklyn7000 21 AVENUE
- K–5 Elementary
3
P.S. 205 Clarion6701 20 AVENUE
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
4
P.S. 204 Vince Lombardi8101 15 AVENUE
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
5
P.S. 186 Dr. Irving A Gladstone7601 19 AVENUE
- K–5 Elementary
6
P.S. 112 Lefferts Park7115 15 AVENUE
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
7
P.S. 128 Bensonhurst2075 84 Street
- K–5 Elementary
8
Not ratedYeshiva Toldos Yesuscher1536 62 STREET
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
9
Not ratedCongregation Machne Chaim Inc6101 16 AVENUE
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
10
Not ratedSinai Academic Center2025 79 STREET
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
11
Not ratedYaldeinu School (The)1600 63 STREET
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
12
Not ratedYeshiva Ketana Of Bensonhurst2025 67 STREET
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
13
Not ratedYeshiva Ohel Moshe7914 BAY PARKWAY
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
14
Not ratedCongregation Machna Shalva1462 62 STREET
- Pre-K / 3-K
- K–5 Elementary
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the best elementary school in Bensonhurst?
- Success Academy Charter School - Bensonhurst ranks highest by our overall rating (95/100), ahead of P.S. 247 Brooklyn. The best fit depends on your child — Smart Match (Motley Pro) ranks schools against your family's priorities.
- How many elementary schools are in Bensonhurst?
- There are 14 elementary schools in Bensonhurst.
- How are these schools ranked?
- By our overall rating — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. The Approaching / Meeting / Exceeding bands are our thresholds, not New York State levels. Smart Match (Motley Pro) weighs academics, diversity, programs, distance from home, and special-education needs against your family's priorities.
Which of these fits your child?
Smart Match (Motley Pro) ranks the schools in your area against your family's priorities — academics, distance from home, diversity, programs, and special-education needs.
Find the right fit →