Categories
Quick searches
Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island features the vast Pelham Bay Park, City Island's nautical village, and waterfront living. More suburban character than much of the Bronx.
Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island features the vast Pelham Bay Park, City Island's nautical village, and waterfront living. More suburban character than much of the Bronx.
Did you know?
City Island has been building boats since the Civil War — the island's boatyards have launched six America's Cup defenders, more than any other single location.
Who’s your neighbor?
Housing cost
$376 / sq ft
Commute
Weekday mornings · leaving 7:30–9:00
- FromPelham Bay-Country Club-City Island
- ToNear Bryant Park
Family scores
Show 5 moreShow fewer
Trade-offs
Stands out
- Affordability79/100
Lower costs than most
To weigh
- Family-Friendly Vibe7/100
Fewer families with children than most
- Schools30/100
Weaker results at the public and charter schools serving it, or fewer of them
- Transit33/100
Longer weekday-morning trips to the city's main job centers
Each score compares it with NYC's other residential neighborhoods.
What these scores don't measure: how a block feels on foot, what's changing on it, and whether a particular school suits your child. Walk it at school drop-off time, and check the zoned school for the exact address before you sign a lease.
Your family’s read
How does Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island fit your family?
An agentic read of this neighborhood — including safety and cost of living — tailored to your priorities, family size, budget, and commute.
Analyze for My FamilySchools & early education
Schools8 schools
Pelham Bay and City Island serve up a genuinely mixed roster — you've got zoned public schools like P.S. 175 on City Island and P.S. 071 Rose E. Scala, plus the Earl Monroe New Renaissance Basketball Charter School. The private and parochial side includes options like the Greek American Institute and Villa Maria Academy, with a few schools showing up in both public and private versions. The split sits at five public, five private, and one charter, which gives families a few different tracks to explore.
Browse all early-ed in this neighborhoodLiving here
Parks & Playgrounds3 places
Pelham Bay and City Island offer just a couple of playgrounds — Ambrosini Field and Colucci Playground serve the area's younger residents. The broader neighborhood leans more toward waterfront access and natural scenery than dedicated play infrastructure, so families may find themselves heading to nearby areas for more robust options. That said, the two playgrounds here provide the basics for quick outdoor time.
Nearest large park: Pelham Bay Park · ~8 min walk (0.3 mi)
Transportation46 stops
The 6 train is your lifeline here — three stops (Buhre Av, Middletown Rd, and Pelham Bay Park) thread through the area, but you're looking at roughly 45 minutes to Midtown Manhattan on a good day. A decent bus network spreads across Country Club and City Island, filling in the gaps the subway leaves, though most residents lean on a car for real flexibility. Transit options are thinner than in more central Bronx neighborhoods, but what exists is reliable.
Restaurants69 places
This stretch runs heavy on pizza and delis — there's a real bench of slice shops and sandwich spots along the main corridors, with City Island holding its own as a separate little eats district with diners, Greek, and a couple of hibachi options. The Thai place on Westchester is a nice outlier, and the Chinese takeout spots cluster near Pelham Bay station. It's not trendy, but there's honest, solid variety if you know where to look.
Groceries3 places
Groceries here mean a quick trip to Key Food on Westchester Avenue or the CTown on City Island — solid basics, nothing fancy. There's also an IGA on the island if you want to combine errands with that side trip. For a proper weekly shop, most families find they need a car; transit options are thin and you're looking at carrying bags back on the bus.
Coffee Shops5 places
Coffee options are thin on the ground here, with just a handful of spots scattered across Pelham Bay and City Island. Dunkin anchors the Westchester Ave stretch for quick, reliable caffeine runs, while a few independent cafes — including Clipper Coffee on City Island and Malsori Coffee Bar near the Pelham Bay border — serve the neighborhood's quieter coffee needs. It's not a third-wave destination by any stretch, but locals have their haunts.
Things to Do7 places
Pelham Bay and City Island offer a lean but athletic-leaning lineup for families with kids. There's a solid martial arts presence — a couple of studios covering jiu-jitsu and broader disciplines — plus a basketball academy and a dance studio for families leaning creative. Enrichment options are thinner, just a small maritime museum on City Island, though the broader Bronx recreational landscape helps fill gaps. It's not a sprawling kids' activity hub, but what's here covers the active-kid basics without much else required.
Daycare & informal care3 places
Pelham Bay and City Island offer a modest but solid mix of Pre-K sites and daycares — four Pre-K options (including a few school-based programs) and three private daycares clustered along the main corridors near Westchester Avenue and Bruckner Boulevard. The selection isn't overwhelming, but families will find a workable spread without having to venture far. Morning drop-off logistics are generally manageable given the area's lower traffic compared to busier Bronx stretches, though scheduling flexibility depends on individual program availability.
Family Resources2 places
The family resource scene here is thin but what exists is solid — City Island Library on City Island Avenue anchors the neighborhood with storytimes and community programming, while Ambrosini Field provides a welcome Recreation outlet at the far end of City Island. The geographic spread means Pelham Bay families don't have much in the way of public anchors nearby, though what's here tends to be well-used and well-loved.
Healthcare3 places
Healthcare options in this stretch of the Bronx are thin — families will likely head elsewhere for pediatricians and any serious medical needs, since neither appear on the local map right now. There is one urgent care option tucked in toward Ampere Avenue, and a couple of private dental practices (Dr. Landisi’s and Greco) handle the basics. For hospitals, the nearest anchors are outside the immediate area, so building a care team means casting a slightly wider net than you might in denser neighborhoods.
Compare with nearby neighborhoods
Best schools in Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island
Schools in Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island
8
Early education in Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island
9
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island a good neighborhood for families?
- Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island scores 40/100 for families on Motley — near the middle of the pack citywide. The Family Fit score blends six parts: how many families live there, schools, affordability, weekday-morning transit time to job centers, safety, and air quality and child health.
- What are the pros and cons of Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island for families?
- For families, Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island stands out for lower costs than most. What to weigh: fewer families with children than most; weaker results at the public and charter schools serving it, or fewer of them; and longer weekday-morning trips to the city's main job centers. Each score compares it with NYC's other residential neighborhoods. They don't measure how a block feels on foot or whether a particular school suits your child, so walk it before you decide.
- Is Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island safe?
- Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island scores 52/100 on safety — near the middle of the pack citywide. We build the score from NYPD crime complaints, pedestrian and cyclist injuries, and serious (Class C) housing violations, each counted per 1,000 residents.
- How are the schools in Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island?
- Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island has 8 schools mapped inside its boundary and scores 30/100 for schools — toward the lower end citywide.
- How do middle and high school admissions work from Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island?
- Middle school: families in Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island apply in 5th grade through the citywide middle school application. District 8's 25 middle school programs admit by method: 14 unscreened, 7 charter lottery, 2 screened and 2 zoned. District 11's 44 middle school programs admit by method: 22 unscreened, 10 zoned, 8 charter lottery and 4 screened. High school: one citywide application in 8th grade lets a family rank programs anywhere in the city, and the eight specialized high schools admit on the SHSAT alone.
- Is Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island affordable?
- Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island scores 79/100 for affordability on Motley — more affordable than most NYC neighborhoods.
- Which borough is Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island in?
- Pelham Bay-Country Club-City Island is a neighborhood in Bronx, New York City.
Want personalized insights for your family?
Sign in to get an agentic neighborhood analysis — including safety and cost of living — tailored to your priorities, family size, budget, and commute.