Motley
Marine Park-Plumb Island, Brooklyn

Marine Park-Plumb Island

At A Glance

Non-residential. Marine Park and Plumb Island include salt marshes and a small island in Jamaica Bay, providing habitat for wildlife and passive waterfront recreation.

Want personalized insights for your family?

Get an agentic neighborhood analysis — including safety and cost of living — tailored to your priorities, family size, budget, and commute.

Analyze for My Family

Places of Interest

Neighborhood Stats

2Schools
6Parks & Playgrounds
1Coffee Shops

Avg Rent

NAper month

Avg Sale Price

NAmedian sale

Top-rated schools

Who’s your neighbor?

0%Under 18
0%College+
0%Own Their Home

What families should know

Schools

2

Both schools anchor the community's educational landscape — J.H.S. 278 Marine Park handles middle schoolers at 1925 Stuart Street, while P.S. 277 Gerritsen Beach covers elementary grades on Gerritsen Avenue. It's a straightforward public school picture here with no charter or private alternatives in the immediate area. Families wanting more governance variety will find the options thin within Marine Park-Plumb Island itself.

Parks & Playgrounds

6

Marine Park is the big score here — a deep bench of playgrounds clustered in one green stretch. You've got Dr John's Playground, Lenape Playground, and Lew Fidler Park all packed in together, plus a few more scattered through the park. The tree canopy over the playground area is solid, and the whole Marine Park green gives it a real park-day feel despite being in a more industrial corner of Brooklyn.

Transportation

19

Buses are your lifeline here — Marine Park sits deep in southeastern Brooklyn with no subway station in sight, so the network along Avenue U, Fillmore Avenue, and Flatbush Avenue is what gets you to the rest of the city. Service runs regularly enough for daily commutes, but expect a trek if you're heading to Manhattan; you're looking at a bus-to-train transfer or a lengthy ride to get anywhere near the core. The stops along Gerritsen Avenue cover the neighborhood well, but this is transit-dependent living — a car helps, though many neighbors get by without one.

Restaurants

Gerritsen Avenue runs as the main drag for grabbing a bite, with a solid lineup of bagels, pizza slices, and delis that keep things practical. A couple of crab shacks and lobster spots pull in the seafood crowd, while a few laid-back bars dot the block for evening hangs. Ice cream shops pop up along the way — a nice surprise for a neighborhood that otherwise keeps it casual and low-key. It's not a destination dining scene, but there's solid variety for what you'd actually want on a given night.

Coffee Shops

1

Marine Park-Plumb Island keeps it minimal when it comes to coffee culture — there's essentially one option, a Dunkin' nested inside a Gulf gas station on Shore Parkway. Beyond that, the neighborhood doesn't offer much in the way of dedicated coffee spots, so residents often combine their caffeine runs with other errands or venture to nearby commercial areas. It's not a destination for specialty coffee, but the basics are covered.

Things to Do

6

This stretch of Brooklyn's southeastern edge is all about the water — a deep bench of beaches lines the coast, making sand and sun the default backdrop. Plumb Beach, Point Breeze, and Dead Horse Beach anchor the area, while Marine Park adds a different flavor with its open green space and basketball courts. The mix leans athletic and outdoorsy, though beyond the shoreline and those courts, options thin out quickly.

Daycare & informal care

Childcare options here are essentially a single point of access — there's one Pre-K site through the public school system, and standalone daycares don't appear in the current mix. For families needing more than universal Pre-K, nearby neighborhoods will likely be the play. The morning drop-off follows the elementary school rhythm, so factoring in that school-year timing matters.

Neighborhood map

Frequently Asked Questions
Is Marine Park-Plumb Island a good neighborhood for families?
Marine Park-Plumb Island scores 34/100 for families on Motley — toward the lower end citywide. The Family Fit score blends safety, schools, parks, cost of living, and community.
Is Marine Park-Plumb Island safe?
Marine Park-Plumb Island scores 90/100 on safety — ahead of most NYC neighborhoods. We build the score from NYPD complaint data, normalized by population.
How are the schools in Marine Park-Plumb Island?
Marine Park-Plumb Island has 2 schools mapped inside its boundary and scores 14/100 for schools — toward the lower end citywide.
Is Marine Park-Plumb Island affordable?
Marine Park-Plumb Island scores 51/100 for affordability on Motley — mid-range on cost for the city.
Which borough is Marine Park-Plumb Island in?
Marine Park-Plumb Island is a neighborhood in Brooklyn, New York City.

Want personalized insights for your family?

Sign in to get an agentic neighborhood analysis — including safety and cost of living — tailored to your priorities, family size, budget, and commute.