Astor Collegiate Academy

Test score data is not provided, making it difficult to directly assess academic performance against the district averages of 57% ELA and 56% Math proficiency. However, the school offers AP Courses alongside STEM and world language instruction (Italian and Spanish), and programs like the Hostos-sponsored after-school science program suggest an intentional pipeline toward college readiness. The 100% teacher rating on instruction quality suggests confidence in classroom delivery, though the lack of proficiency data means parents should ask specifically about student progress and Regents performance.

This is where Astor Collegiate stands out — and it’s remarkable. Teacher instruction quality scores a perfect 100%, parent-teacher trust hits 95%, and parent-principal trust is 94%. There were zero suspensions in the reporting period, a stark contrast to the district average of nearly 0.5%. That doesn’t mean there are no behavioral challenges — it suggests a restorative or supportive approach to discipline. Teacher trust in leadership (84%) and collegial trust (84%) are solid though slightly lower, and the very low survey response rates (27 teacher responses, 66 family responses) mean these strong numbers come from a smaller subset and should be interpreted with some caution. Still, the direction is unmistakable: families and teachers feel good about this school’s climate.

The student body is predominantly Hispanic (46%) and Black (27%), with meaningful Asian (9%) and White (15%) representation — a diverse mix reflected in the 73% diversity index. Nearly a quarter of students have IEPs, and the 78% economic need index means most families are navigating significant financial challenges. The neighborhood’s low homeownership (16%) and BA+ education rate (21%) tell you these are working-class families investing in their children’s futures. The 17% family survey response rate is on the lower side, though the high trust scores among respondents suggest an engaged core community.

Allerton sits in the east Bronx with a strong family density score (73%) and excellent stability (84%), meaning many long-term residents. The poverty rate is 24.7% and median household income is $46,623 — clearly a working-class neighborhood. Transit access is moderate (56%), but safety scores are low (12 out of 100), with elevated crime density and asthma rates that are notable health concerns. The area has seen waves of new housing (median home value $535K), suggesting ongoing neighborhood change. There are parks and local businesses along major corridors, and the neighborhood feels residential and rooted.

Allerton is walkable with good street-level activity along major avenues. Families from further afield rely on public transit — the area has decent bus connections and is accessible by several lines. Driving is manageable but parking can be challenging during school hours.