Motley
District 1616

Brooklyn Brownstone School

272 Macdonough Street

At a Glance

A small neighborhood elementary where academic gains have outpaced nearly every peer in the district

Best suited for

Families looking for a small, tight-knit neighborhood elementary with strong academics and an unusually calm, high-trust climate — especially parents who value being part of a rooted Bed-Stuy school community and are comfortable with a modestly sized school rather than a large campus with extensive programming.

Overall Rating

84
Meeting
Not MeetingApproachingMeetingExceeding
ELA87.4
Math81.1

Rating = average of NY State ELA + math proficiency, grades 3–8

Bands are Motley's thresholds on a 0–100 scale, not New York State performance levels.

How this is scored→

What stands out

  • Academic transformation: ELA proficiency climbed from roughly 54% to 87% and math from 45% to 81% over six years
  • Three consecutive years with zero suspensions, against a district suspension rate of about 1%
  • 100% teacher-reported safety, well above the district average of 94%
  • 98% of families report strong relationships with the school — one of the strongest community bonds in the district
  • Grade 3 proficiency hits 91% ELA and 94% math, showing students are reading and computing at a high level by the end of early elementary

Things to consider

  • Chronic absenteeism is reported at 78.8%, which is high and worth asking the school about directly, even though the overall attendance rate (93.3%) is strong
  • PTA fundraising of about $66 per student is slightly below the district average of $69, meaning fewer enrichment dollars from family contributions
  • With only 307 students, the school offers fewer electives, sports, and extracurricular variety than larger elementary schools
  • Teacher survey responses were relatively low (28 staff), so the staff-side climate numbers represent a smaller voice than the family surveys

Based on 2024-25 data

School SummaryDistrict 16

Among traditional public schools in District 16, Brooklyn Brownstone stands out clearly — its peer elementary schools (P.S. 40, P.S. 262, P.S. 5, P.S. 21) score in the high 70s to low 80s on the district's own ratings, while Brooklyn Brownstone sits well above that range. The only local school scoring higher is a charter (Success Academy Bed-Stuy 3), which operates under a different accountability structure.

Academics

Improving

The academic story here is about trajectory, not just standing. In 2019, only about 54% of students were ELA-proficient and 45% math-proficient — close to district norms. By 2025, those numbers jumped to 87% ELA and 81% math, well above district averages of roughly 58% and 57% respectively. The overall quality score of 3.37/4 sits comfortably above the district's 2.29 average. Grade 3 results are especially strong (91% ELA, 94% math), with grades 4 and 5 still well above district norms but showing a slight step down. This kind of year-over-year climb suggests real instructional improvement, not a one-year fluke.

Culture

moderate

The day-to-day feel here is warm and stable. Teachers report 100% safety and strong collegial trust (96%), and families report near-universal satisfaction (94%) and very high trust in both teachers (96%) and the principal (96%). Strong family-school relationships score at 98%. Discipline data backs up the surveys — zero suspensions in each of the last three years, compared to a district average suspension rate of 1%. Teacher survey participation was modest (28 responses), so the staff-side numbers come from a smaller voice and are worth weighing with that in mind.

Community

The student body is 68% Black, 14% White, 12% Hispanic, and smaller shares of multiracial, Asian, and Native American students — a community that reflects the historic Black character of Bed-Stuy while including a meaningful white presence that's common in parts of the neighborhood. About 15% of students have IEPs and the economic need index sits at 57.5%, indicating a mixed-income population. The diversity index of 57% reflects a school that's more homogeneously rooted in one community than it is a melting pot.

Neighborhood

Bedford-Stuyvesant (East)

The school sits in Bedford-Stuyvesant (East), where median household income is around $70,755 and about 23% of residents live below the poverty line. Roughly 12% of households have children, and 41% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher. Homeownership is relatively low (27%), and the median home value north of $1.1 million reflects the wave of brownstone investment that has reshaped parts of the neighborhood. It's a community in transition — historically rooted, increasingly diverse in income and education.

Families have a couple of solid options nearby. The C train at Kingston-Throop Aves is about a six-minute walk, and the A and C at Utica Avenue are about seven minutes. The 3 and 4 at Crown Heights–Utica Avenue is farther — roughly an eighteen-minute walk.

Academic Performance

ELA Proficiency

87.4%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State ELA exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Math Proficiency

81.1%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State Math exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Historical Trends

ELA Math

The dashed line marks 2023, when New York changed its grades 3–8 state tests. Scores before and after it aren’t directly comparable.

2020–2021 data unavailable due to COVID-19

Source: NYC DOE School Quality Reports

Survey Results

Family Feedback
Satisfaction
94%
Teacher Trust
96%
Principal Trust
96%
Relationships
98%
Teacher Perspective
Instruction
89%
Principal Trust
87%
Collegial Trust
96%
Safety
100%

NYC School Survey (2025) · 218 families responded (63% rate)

Racial & Ethnic Diversity

Moderate
12%Hispanic/Latino
68%Black
14%White
2%Asian
3%Multi-Racial
1%Native American

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

PTA Fundraising

2024-25
$20,233
total raised
$66
per student

Source: DOE Local Law 171 disclosure

Discipline

0suspensions (0% of students)
3-Year Trend— Stable
21
22
23

NYSED Student & Educator Database (2023-24)

Economic Need & Special Populations

Economic Need Index
57.5%
IEP Students
14.7%

How to get in, step by step

Pre-K

Brooklyn Brownstone School also has Pre-K classes. They're a separate application from kindergarten, made on MySchools.

Pre-K application

Applications typically open in the winter and close in the spring, with offers in late spring; the city announces exact dates each year.

Kindergarten

Brooklyn Brownstone School doesn't have an attendance zone of its own, so living nearby doesn't guarantee a seat here. Families apply on MySchools, and seats go to the school's priority groups first, then by random lottery.

Kindergarten application

Opens
Wed, Dec 9
Closes
Fri, Jan 22
Offers
Tue, Mar 30

The DOE’s published dates.

  1. 1Apply on MySchools during the kindergarten application.
  2. 2Rank this school with your zoned school, if you have one, and any others you'd take — in true preference order.

Open houses and tours

We haven’t seen open-house dates for this school yet.

From the MySchools admissions calendar, checked weekly.

Free account

Make this school part of your plan

Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.

Save this school to a shortlist, next to the neighborhoods you're weighing
Tell us about your family once — grades, priorities, where you live
Get a read on any neighborhood for your family
Ask Motley Intelligence about this school, with your family in mind
Sign In — It’s Free

No credit card required

Compare head-to-head

Explore nearby

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Brooklyn Brownstone School a good school?
On Motley, Brooklyn Brownstone School earns an overall rating of 84/100 — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. Its state test results run above the District 16 average.
What grades does Brooklyn Brownstone School serve?
Brooklyn Brownstone School serves grades Pre-K to 5.
Is Brooklyn Brownstone School public, charter, or private?
Brooklyn Brownstone School is a public school in NYC Community School District 16.
What neighborhood is Brooklyn Brownstone School in?
Brooklyn Brownstone School is in Bedford-Stuyvesant (East), Brooklyn.