J.H.S. 223 The Montauk

Test scores at The Montauk are below the District 20 average: 51.7% ELA proficiency versus 66% district-wide, and 61% math versus 71% district-wide. The school has shown an uneven trajectory — scores climbed steadily from 2016 to 2019 (ELA from 30% to 50%, math from 47% to 59%), then dipped in 2022-2023 before recovering somewhat. Grade 7 performs strongest with 55% ELA and 63% math proficiency, while Grade 8 trails at 50% ELA. Science proficiency at 36% is notably lower than math and ELA.

The survey data tells a striking story: 94% of parents report satisfaction and trust in teachers, 95% trust the principal, and 92% of teachers say instruction quality is strong. These numbers rival or exceed district averages. Yet the day-to-day reality shows red flags. Chronic absenteeism sits at a staggering 76% — far above the district average — with Asian students missing the most (86%). The suspension rate is 4%, dramatically higher than the district average of 0.3%, though it has held steady after spiking from 4 to 25 suspensions between 2021-2023. Teacher collegial trust is solid at 81%, though lower than the parent trust numbers.

The school enrolls 790 students in a building that feels full but not overcrowded, with an average class size of 25 matching the district average. The student body is 52% Asian, 33% Hispanic, 11% White, and 2% Black, giving it a diversity index of 62%. The economic need index of 88% is very high — most families here qualify for free or reduced lunch. This mirrors the neighborhood, which has a 33% poverty rate and median household income of $52,000. At 15%, the IEP population is moderate.

Borough Park is a family-heavy neighborhood (97% family density) with strong immigrant roots, particularly from China, Eastern Europe, and Latin America. The area is known for its dense population, local businesses, and multigenerational households. Transit access is moderate (58th percentile), and safety scores are average (53rd percentile). The neighborhood has low stability and health environment scores, reflecting its high-density, urban character. Parks and recreation spaces are available but not abundant.

The neighborhood is highly walkable with good foot traffic, though parents from farther-flung parts of District 20 may find the commute longer. Families often walk or take public transit.