At a Glance
A neighborhood Catholic school where every kid plays violin, takes ballroom, and knows every teacher by name.
Best suited for
Catholic families — especially those rooted in East Harlem — who want a faith-based, affordable elementary education with real arts exposure and a small community, and who can manage a longer commute.
What stands out
- Tuition of $3,400 is among the lowest of any private elementary school in Manhattan — a real lifeline for working- and middle-income families priced out of the independent-school market.
- An unusually full arts menu for a school this small and this affordable: violin, percussion ensemble, vocal music, ballroom dancing, and an art club.
- Total enrollment of just 157 students means teachers and staff can realistically know every child by name and family circumstance.
- Ballroom dancing in an elementary curriculum is genuinely rare in NYC — it's the kind of program that builds poise and a willingness to try something awkward.
- Parish-school roots mean the school is woven into a broader faith community, with sacramental preparation and liturgical life as part of the year.
Things to consider
- Parent reviews surface real concerns about teacher and principal turnover, communication gaps, and bullying issues in grades 4-5 — worth asking directly about current leadership stability and how the school handles peer conflict at the upper grades.
- The school ends at fifth grade, so families will need a separate middle-school plan by the time their child is 11.
- The commute is meaningfully long for a young child — every nearby subway is an 11-to-14-minute walk, which limits the practical catchment area.
- With a 13:1 student-teacher ratio and only 12 FTE teachers, a single departure can ripple through the school in ways it wouldn't at a larger institution.
- As a parish school, program offerings depend on the financial health of the parish and donations — enrichment programs are not guaranteed year to year.
Identity
Mt Carmel-Holy Rosary is a coeducational Roman Catholic elementary school serving pre-K through fifth grade, accredited by the National Catholic Educational Association. The school describes itself as combining teaching and technology with traditional values in a close-knit, caring atmosphere, with a stated commitment to academic rigor. As a parish school, its mission is rooted in serving the local Catholic community rather than competing on selectivity.
Community
The student body is roughly 47% Black and 47% Hispanic, with a small multiracial contingent and very few white or Asian families — a mix that mirrors the surrounding East Harlem neighborhood. With 157 students total, this is a tight community where most families live within walking distance of the school and likely attend Mass at the parish. The Catholic identity draws families seeking faith formation alongside academics, and the school's affordability opens the door to families who couldn't consider most NYC private schools.
Neighborhood
East Harlem north of 110th Street is a working-class, predominantly Latino and Black neighborhood where the median household income sits around $36,700 and about a third of residents live below the poverty line. The area has deep Puerto Rican and African-American roots, with a strong street culture, active churches, and a growing number of new developments along the avenues. Mt Carmel-Holy Rosary sits within this community as both a school and a parish anchor.
There's no quick subway hop — the 116 St (6) is about an 11-minute walk, 125 St (4, 5, 6) about 12 minutes, and 110 St (6) about 14 minutes, so most families will be walking, biking, or arranging their own drop-off rather than relying on transit.
Notable Programs
What Parents Are Saying
Mixed reviews; concerns about teacher/principal turnover, bullying issues in grades 4-5, and communication problems; some parents appreciated the school until issues arose
Synthesized from public parent reviews · Apr 2026
Make this school part of your plan
Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.
No credit card required
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL a good school?
- Published quality ratings aren't available for MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL yet on Motley. It's a private school serving grades Pre-K to 5 in East Harlem (North).
- What grades does MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL serve?
- MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL serves grades Pre-K to 5.
- How do students get into MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL?
- MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL runs its own private admissions process — typically an application, a visit, and sometimes testing.
- Is MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL public, charter, or private?
- MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL is a private school.
- What neighborhood is MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL in?
- MT CARMEL-HOLY ROSARY SCHOOL is in East Harlem (North), Manhattan.