Motley
District 99

New Directions Secondary School

240 EAST 172 STREET

At a Glance

A tiny high school in the Bronx where families feel deeply heard but academic performance is among the city's lowest

Best suited for

Families who prioritize a small, intimate school community with exceptionally strong family-teacher relationships over academic rigor. This school may work for students who thrive in low-pressure environments with plenty of individual attention and who benefit from rich extracurricular offerings. Parents should be prepared to provide significant academic support at home or through outside tutoring, and must prioritize addressing the chronic attendance challenges. Students with high academic aspirations or those seeking competitive coursework may struggle here.

What stands out
  • Exceptional family trust scores — 100% parent-teacher and parent-principal trust, 99% satisfaction
  • Zero suspensions reported — a discipline approach that prioritizes keeping students in school
  • Remarkably rich programming for a small school — 12+ sports teams, music clubs, language instruction, wellness programs
  • Very small enrollment (139 students) allows for intimate, personalized attention
  • 94% family survey response rate indicates strong community engagement
Things to consider
  • Academic performance is among the lowest in NYC — 5.4% ELA and 1.8% math proficiency
  • Daily attendance at only 63.2% is a serious red flag despite high parent trust
  • Teacher instruction quality (79%) lags behind district average (90%)
  • Science proficiency at 0% — no students met grade-level standards
  • Chronic absenteeism of 16.2% suggests daily attendance barriers
  • Small size means limited course offerings and less academic competition
  • Students with higher academic ambitions may need significant outside support

Based on 2019 data

School SummaryDistrict 9

Among District 9 peer schools, New Directions Secondary School does not appear in the top-performing list, which includes charter schools scoring 79-99/100. The peer comparison schools (Icahn Charter School 1 at 99/100, Success Academy Bronx 2 at 97/100) represent a very different academic tier. This school serves a different population with different needs — one that values community connection over academic performance metrics, based on the survey data.

AcademicsImproving

Test scores here are significantly below district and city averages — 5.4% ELA proficiency and 1.8% math proficiency compared to district averages around 45%. No students demonstrated science proficiency on the most recent assessments. However, there is a modest upward trend: ELA proficiency has climbed from 1.8% in 2016 to 5.4% in 2019, and math from 0% to 1.8% over the same period. This suggests the school is slowly improving but remains far from meeting grade-level expectations. Teacher instruction quality scores (79%) also fall below the district average of 90%, indicating that instructional challenges persist.

Culturestrong

The survey data reveals a striking disconnect between family trust and academic outcomes. Parents report near-universal satisfaction (99%) and 100% trust in both teachers and the principal — extraordinary scores that suggest strong relationship-building. Teachers also report high collegial trust (95%) and strong trust in leadership (88%). However, daily attendance is a serious concern at just 63.2%, well below the district average of 90%, with 16.2% of students chronically absent. There were zero suspensions last year, which could indicate either strong behavior management or under-reporting. The combination of high trust but low attendance suggests families believe in the school community but struggle with getting students through the door consistently.

Community

The student body is predominantly Hispanic (61%) and Black (34%), reflecting the demographics of the surrounding Mount Eden-Claremont neighborhood. With a diversity index of 49%, the school is fairly homogeneous in terms of race but serves a community with significant socioeconomic diversity. Twenty percent of students have IEPs, indicating substantial special education support needs. The school is very small with only 139 students total, which means class sizes are manageable (averaging 20.8 students) but extracurricular communities are tight-knit.

NeighborhoodMount Eden-Claremont (West)

Mount Eden-Claremont (West) is a densely populated, family-oriented Bronx neighborhood with significant economic challenges. Median household income is $45,405, and 32% of residents live below the poverty line. Only 4.4% of residents own homes, meaning most families rent. The neighborhood scores very high on family density (95th percentile) and transit access (84th percentile), making it accessible for families without cars. However, education orientation is low (25th percentile), suggesting fewer college-going cultural norms in the area. Safety scores (77 out of 100) indicate moderate concerns, with elevated asthma rates and lead exposure risks noted in environmental indicators.

The neighborhood is highly walkable with strong transit access (83.52 score), and the high family density means many students live within walking distance. Families relying on public transportation will find this location accessible via several bus routes.

Academic Performance

ELA Proficiency

5.4%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State ELA exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Math Proficiency

1.8%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State Math exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Science Proficiency

0%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State Science exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Survey Results

Family Feedback
Satisfaction
99%
Teacher Trust
100%
Principal Trust
100%
Teacher Perspective
Instruction
79%
Principal Trust
88%
Collegial Trust
95%

NYC School Survey (2025) · 125 families responded (94% rate)

Programs & Activities

Academic(1)
Humanities
Arts(1)
Glee And Other Music Clubs
Sports(12)
BaseballBasketballBowlingCross CountryDouble DutchFlag FootballIndoor TrackOutdoor TrackSoccerSoftballVolleyballWrestling
Language(3)
ELL SupportFrenchSpanish
Clubs & Activities(3)
During-School Day Mentoring And/Or CounselingPsal SportsSchool Wellness Council Sponsored Activities

Admissions Demand

New Directions Secondary SchoolCompetitive

New Directions has a rolling admissions policy and operates as a transfer high school.

Seats18
Applicants67
Apps/Seat3.7
Offer Rate25%

Racial & Ethnic Diversity

Moderate
61%Hispanic/Latino
34%Black
1%White
1%Asian
2%Native American

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Economic Need & Special Populations

IEP Students
20.1%

Discipline

0suspensions

NYSED Student & Educator Database

Frequently Asked Questions
Is New Directions Secondary School a good school?
On Motley, New Directions Secondary School earns an overall quality score of 4/100 — a blend of New York State ELA and math results, attendance, and the school-climate survey. Its state test results run below the District 9 average.
What grades does New Directions Secondary School serve?
New Directions Secondary School serves grades 9 to 12.
Is New Directions Secondary School public, charter, or private?
New Directions Secondary School is a public school in NYC Community School District 9.
What neighborhood is New Directions Secondary School in?
New Directions Secondary School is in Mount Eden-Claremont (West), Bronx.
Premium Details

Get the complete picture

Motley pulls together data from across New York City so you don’t have to. One free account, every school.

Data from 15+ NYC agencies on every school
Personalized school matching for your family
Save schools and build your research board
Sign In — It’s Free

No credit card required

Get all this when you sign in

Survey data, program listings, admissions stats, and the full editorial profile — free, no credit card.

Full School Profile

Skip the tour guessing game. Get the standout features, honest trade-offs, and whether your kid will actually thrive here — before you visit.

Survey Results

See what 2,600+ schools’ own families and teachers really think — trust, safety, instruction quality — so you walk in with the truth, not the brochure.

Programs & Activities

Stop Googling program lists. AP courses, STEM labs, dual-language tracks, sports teams, arts — all categorized so you can compare schools in minutes.

Admissions Demand

Know your odds before you apply. Apps-per-seat ratios, offer rates, and fill data — so you don’t waste your top choice on a long shot.

Economic Need & Special Populations

Find out if the support your child needs is actually there — IEP enrollment, economic need index, and the demographics no other site surfaces.

Discipline

One bad year doesn’t tell you much. Three years of state-verified suspension data shows whether things are getting better or worse.

Sign In — It’s Free