Motley
District 22
CharterDistrict 2 →Charter Lottery

New York City Charter School of the Arts

241 WATER STREET

At a Glance

An arts-focused charter middle school in Lower Manhattan whose test scores have nearly doubled in five years

Best suited for

Families drawn to an arts-themed middle school who are comfortable with a lottery admissions process, willing to commute into Lower Manhattan, and who prioritize a small school environment with strong teacher relationships over top-tier test scores on day one.

Overall Rating

65
Approaching
Not MeetingApproachingMeetingExceeding
ELA70.6
Math59.2

Rating = average of NY State ELA + math proficiency, grades 3–8

Bands are Motley's thresholds on a 0–100 scale, not New York State performance levels.

How this is scored→

What stands out

  • Arts-integrated mission reflected in the school's name and curriculum framing
  • Dramatic multi-year academic growth — ELA proficiency has roughly doubled since 2017
  • Teacher-reported instructional quality (95%) and teacher-principal trust (96%) both exceed district averages
  • Charter lottery means families from outside the immediate neighborhood can attend
  • Small middle school size (about 247 students) allows for tighter adult-student relationships

Things to consider

  • Math proficiency at 59.2% sits about 13 percentage points below the district average — the most significant academic gap
  • Chronic absenteeism at 66.3% is a serious flag that deserves a direct conversation with the school before enrolling
  • With 26% of students having IEPs, families should ask how special education services are staffed and delivered
  • Family survey response rate is just 24%, so parent-survey numbers may not reflect the full parent body
  • Located in a neighborhood with very few resident children — most families will commute
  • Sits below high-performing District 2 peers like Lower Lab and P.S. 290 on the overall quality review

Based on 2025 data

School SummaryDistrict 2

District 2 includes some of the most sought-after schools in New York City — Lower Lab (99/100), Success Academy Union Square (95/100), and P.S. 290 (95/100) all rank at the very top. This charter sits below that tier on the overall quality review (2.6 out of 4 versus a district average of 2.9), and its proficiency rates trail district averages. Within the charter landscape specifically, it tells a stronger growth story than its current snapshot might suggest.

Academics

Improving

This school's academic trajectory is one of the more dramatic turnaround stories in the data set. ELA proficiency rose from 35.5% in 2017 to 70.6% in 2025, and math climbed from 31.5% to 59.2% over the same period, with the biggest jumps coming after 2021. Even with that growth, the school sits a bit below the district average in ELA (70.6% vs. 73.2%) and noticeably below in math (59.2% vs. 72.5%) — the math gap is the more significant one. Within the building, eighth graders outperform sixth graders in math (66.7% vs. 48.3%), suggesting skills build over time. The school's overall quality review score of 2.6 out of 4 is just below the district average of 2.9.

Culture

concerning

The adults in this building clearly like working with each other. Teachers rate their principal's leadership at 96%, instructional quality at 95%, and collegial trust at 91% — all solid numbers, with instructional quality running notably above the district average of roughly 90%. Parent satisfaction and parent-teacher trust both land at 91%, near the district average. Attendance on a typical day is healthy at 91.2%, essentially in line with the district. The headline concern here is chronic absenteeism: 66.3% of students are chronically absent, which is an unusually high share even in a post-pandemic landscape and something any family should ask the school about directly. Discipline data and a separate teacher-reported safety measure weren't provided in this dataset, so the day-to-day feel on those dimensions can't be characterized from the numbers.

Community

The student body is 40% Hispanic, 34% Black, 18% White, 5% multiracial, and 2% Asian, with a diversity index of 73%. That mix does not match the Financial District around it — the surrounding census tract is largely wealthy, highly educated, and predominantly white. The economic need index of 59.8% tells you that most families here qualify for some level of economic assistance, which is unusual for a school sitting in one of the city's priciest zip codes. About 26% of students have IEPs, a meaningfully higher share than the citywide average, and families should expect a fairly wide range of learning needs in classrooms.

Neighborhood

Financial District-Battery Park City

The Financial District-Battery Park City area is defined by high-rise apartments and corporate office towers rather than block after block of family houses. The census figures tell the story: median household income is $192,111, the poverty rate is 6.1%, 82.7% of adults have a bachelor's degree or higher, and only 13.9% of households have children under 18. Homeownership is just 24.9% and the median home value tops $1.27 million — most residents are renters, many of them transplants working in finance or tech. For families whose kids attend this school, the neighborhood is more of a workplace destination than a residential base, which explains the demographic mismatch.

Getting here by subway is easy. Bowling Green (4, 5) is about a two-minute walk, and Rector St is served by both the R and W lines and the 1 line, each about a three-minute walk from the school.

Academic Performance

ELA Proficiency

70.6%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State ELA exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Math Proficiency

59.2%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State Math exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Historical Trends

ELA Math

The dashed line marks 2023, when New York changed its grades 3–8 state tests. Scores before and after it aren’t directly comparable.

2020–2021 data unavailable due to COVID-19

Source: NYC DOE School Quality Reports

Survey Results

Family Feedback
Satisfaction
91%
Teacher Trust
91%
Principal Trust
91%
Relationships
n/a
Teacher Perspective
Instruction
95%
Principal Trust
96%
Collegial Trust
91%
Safety
n/a

NYC School Survey (2025) · 53 families responded (24% rate)

Racial & Ethnic Diversity

Diverse
40%Hispanic/Latino
34%Black
18%White
2%Asian
5%Multi-Racial

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Economic Need & Special Populations

Economic Need Index
59.8%
IEP Students
25.9%
Free account

Make this school part of your plan

Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.

Save this school to a shortlist, next to the neighborhoods you're weighing
Tell us about your family once — grades, priorities, where you live
Get a read on any neighborhood for your family
Ask Motley Intelligence about this school, with your family in mind
Sign In — It’s Free

No credit card required

Compare head-to-head

Explore nearby

Frequently Asked Questions

Is New York City Charter School of the Arts a good school?
On Motley, New York City Charter School of the Arts earns an overall rating of 65/100 — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. Its state test results run below the District 2 average.
What grades does New York City Charter School of the Arts serve?
New York City Charter School of the Arts serves grades 6 to 8.
How do students get into New York City Charter School of the Arts?
New York City Charter School of the Arts is a charter school — it admits through a free public lottery, with no test or attendance zone.
Is New York City Charter School of the Arts public, charter, or private?
New York City Charter School of the Arts is a public charter school in NYC Community School District 2.
What neighborhood is New York City Charter School of the Arts in?
New York City Charter School of the Arts is in Financial District-Battery Park City, Manhattan.