Motley
Private schoolP
PrivatePrivate

NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL

134 HOWARD AVENUE

At a Glance

A Catholic all-girls school where the mission is to send every graduate out as an agent of change.

Best suited for

A Staten Island family (or a family willing to commute) looking for a faith-centered all-girls high school where leadership, service, and the arts are taken seriously alongside college prep.

What stands out

  • All-girls environment where the explicit goal is empowering young women as leaders and change-makers, not just preparing them for college.
  • Sponsorship by the Sisters of the Congregation of Notre Dame, giving the school a documented mission rooted in a centuries-old educational tradition rather than a generic Catholic identity.
  • A meaningful arts offering — music, dance, and visual arts alongside STEM — unusual for a school of this size and tuition tier.
  • A "Global Citizen" program that frames service and social awareness as part of the core NDA experience, not an afterthought.
  • Reasonable size at roughly 400 students, supporting both a real elective catalog and the kind of teacher-student familiarity parents consistently praise.

Things to consider

  • The 16-minute walk to the Stapleton SIR station means most families will drive, carpool, or arrange buses — not a drop-off-at-the-subway school.
  • As a Catholic school, theology, retreats, service hours, and faith formation are part of the daily experience, not optional extras; families should be comfortable with that.
  • Demographics skew heavily White (81%), so families prioritizing a more racially and culturally diverse peer environment may want to weigh this carefully.
  • Tuition of $12,700–$13,700 is moderate by NYC Catholic-secondary standards but still a meaningful commitment, and some parents in reviews have questioned whether the academic return matches the price.
  • The student-teacher ratio of 19.3:1 is solid but not unusually small — the "teachers know every student" feel parents describe comes from culture, not class size.

Identity

Religious

Founded and still sponsored by the Sisters of the Congregation of Notre Dame, Notre Dame Academy is a Roman Catholic all-girls secondary school serving grades 9 through 12. Its stated mission centers on a "liberating education" that pushes each student toward academic rigor, personal growth, prayer, reflection, and service. The school is accredited by the Middle States Association of Colleges and Schools.

Community

Moderate

The student body is about 81% White, with smaller shares of Hispanic (9%), Asian (6%), and Black (3%) students, reflecting the largely White, middle-to-upper-middle-income character of the Grymes Hill and surrounding neighborhoods. As an all-girls Catholic school with a single-site campus, the community tends to draw from Staten Island families and a smaller commuter pool from other boroughs. Parents consistently describe it as close-knit, with strong family involvement.

Neighborhood

West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill

The school sits in the Grymes Hill / West New Brighton / Silver Lake area of Staten Island, a residential stretch where the median household income is about $109,000 and roughly 42% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher — comfortably above the citywide average. The poverty rate sits around 10%, indicating a broadly stable, college-educated community. Families choosing NDA should expect a true neighborhood campus feel rather than a bustling urban setting.

The nearest subway is Stapleton on the Staten Island Railway, about a 16-minute walk — manageable in good weather but a real consideration on dark winter mornings, and most families drive or arrange carpools.

Notable Programs

STEMMusicDanceVisual ArtsGlobal Citizen

What Parents Are Saying

Generally positive: parents praise close-knit supportive community, teachers who know students by name, beautiful campus, high parent involvement; some concerns about curriculum quality and value for price

Synthesized from public parent reviews · Apr 2026

Free account

Make this school part of your plan

Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.

Save this school to a shortlist, next to the neighborhoods you're weighing
Tell us about your family once — grades, priorities, where you live
Get a read on any neighborhood for your family
Ask Motley Intelligence about this school, with your family in mind
Sign In — It’s Free

No credit card required

Explore nearby

Frequently Asked Questions

Is NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL a good school?
Published quality ratings aren't available for NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL yet on Motley. It's a private school serving grades 9 to 12 in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill.
What grades does NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL serve?
NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL serves grades 9 to 12.
How do students get into NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL?
NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL runs its own private admissions process — typically an application, a visit, and sometimes testing.
Is NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL public, charter, or private?
NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL is a private school.
What neighborhood is NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL in?
NOTRE DAME ACADEMY HIGH SCHOOL is in West New Brighton-Silver Lake-Grymes Hill, Staten Island.