Motley
District 1010
PublicDistrict 10Zoned

P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher

3961 HILLMAN AVENUE

At a Glance

A zoned neighborhood school with very high family satisfaction but significant attendance challenges and uneven academic performance

Best suited for

Families who value a strong home-school relationship and can actively support their children's attendance—parents who will ensure kids are in school every day and engaged. Best suited for families who live within the zone and want a K-8 school, who are comfortable with the school's academic challenges and may need to supplement at home, and who prioritize the positive family culture over raw test scores. Families seeking stronger academic programming or higher-performing schools may want to explore District 10's other options.

What stands out
  • Exceptional parent satisfaction (99%) and parent trust in teachers (98%)
  • Zero suspensions for the past two years—an explicit discipline improvement
  • Strong 4th grade performance (67% math, 55% ELA) shows the school can deliver academic results
  • K-8 structure keeps families in one school through middle school
  • Very high family survey response rate (832 responses) indicates strong community engagement
Things to consider
  • Chronic absenteeism of 57% is alarmingly high—more than half of students miss too much school
  • Teacher-principal trust is low at 55%, and teacher-reported safety at 65% is well below district average
  • Academic performance trails district averages in both subjects
  • Very limited academic programming beyond basic ELL support
  • Low PTA fundraising ($4/student) may mean fewer enrichment resources
  • District 10 has several higher-performing schools nearby

Based on 2024-2025 data

School SummaryDistrict 10

Among the six peer schools in District 10, P.S. 095 falls in the lower-middle tier—outperforming only three schools but behind established higher-performing options like P.S. 024 Spuyten Duyvil (92/100) and P.S. 081 Robert J. Christen (88/100). The overall score of 1.58/4 is below the district average of 1.77, reflecting the challenges here. However, the peer comparison shows meaningful variation within the district, and this school outperforms some alternatives.

AcademicsImproving

Test scores at P.S. 095 fall below the District 10 average—ELA proficiency of 40.5% versus the district's 45%, and math at 38.6% versus 43.5%—placing the school in the lower third of the district. However, the long-term trend is encouraging: both subjects have roughly doubled since 2016, with math showing particularly strong gains in recent years. Performance varies significantly by grade—4th graders excel with 67% math proficiency, while 5th and 6th graders lag. The school lacks robust academic programming beyond basic ELL support, with a program richness score of just 34.7 out of 100.

Cultureconcerning

The culture picture is mixed but leans positive on the family side and concerning on the teacher side. Parents overwhelmingly report feeling heard and trusted—99% satisfaction and 97% principal trust are exceptional. Teachers rate instruction quality highly at 92%. However, only 55% of teachers trust the principal, and just 65% report feeling safe—well below the district average of 87%. Attendance is a real struggle: while 89.3% shows up on average, a striking 56.9% of students are chronically absent, meaning they miss 10% or more of school days. On a positive note, the school has eliminated suspensions entirely over the past two years after four incidents each in the prior two years—a meaningful improvement in discipline climate.

Community

With 962 students in grades K-8, P.S. 095 serves a predominantly Hispanic community (72% of students), reflecting the neighborhood's demographics. About 16% are Black, 6% Asian, and 5% White. The economic need index of 88 is high—nearly 9 in 10 students qualify for free or reduced lunch—indicating significant family financial hardship. About 22% of students have IEPs, and the school provides ELL support for English language learners. The diversity index of 52% is moderate. PTA fundraising is minimal at $4 per student (compared to $74 district-wide), suggesting limited volunteer or fundraising capacity.

NeighborhoodKingsbridge Heights-Van Cortlandt Village

Kingsbridge Heights-Van Cortlandt Village is a dense, transit-rich neighborhood in the Bronx with strong family presence—the family density score of 86.59 is very high, and stability score of 83.52 indicates long-term residents. Median household income is $55,462 with a 21.2% poverty rate. Transit access is excellent at nearly 82, making car-free commuting feasible. However, the neighborhood scores just 7.66 on safety (very low), and education orientation is only 36. Homeownership is low at 18%, meaning most families rent. The area has parks and recreational resources typical of this part of the Bronx.

The neighborhood is highly walkable with strong transit options—many families likely walk or take buses and trains. The excellent transit score (82) suggests car-free commuting is realistic for most.

Academic Performance

ELA Proficiency

40.5%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State ELA exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Math Proficiency

38.6%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State Math exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Science Proficiency

7.3%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State Science exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Survey Results

Family Feedback
Satisfaction
99%
Teacher Trust
98%
Principal Trust
97%
Teacher Perspective
Instruction
92%
Principal Trust
55%
Collegial Trust
77%
Safety
65%

NYC School Survey (2025) · 832 families responded (98% rate)

Programs & Activities

Academic(1)
Accelerated/Honors
Language(1)
ELL Support

Racial & Ethnic Diversity

Moderate
72%Hispanic/Latino
16%Black
5%White
6%Asian
1%Multi-Racial

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

PTA Fundraising

2024-25
$3,562total raised
$4per student

Source: DOE Local Law 171 disclosure

Economic Need & Special Populations

Economic Need Index
88%
IEP Students
21.9%

Discipline

0suspensions (0% of students)
3-Year Trend↓ Declining
21
22
23

NYSED Student & Educator Database (2023-24)

Frequently Asked Questions
Is P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher a good school?
On Motley, P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher earns an overall quality score of 40/100 — a blend of New York State ELA and math results, attendance, and the school-climate survey. Its state test results run in line with the District 10 average.
What grades does P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher serve?
P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher serves grades K to 8.
How do students get into P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher?
P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher admits by zone — families living in its attendance zone are generally guaranteed a seat.
Is P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher public, charter, or private?
P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher is a public school in NYC Community School District 10.
What neighborhood is P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher in?
P.S. 095 Sheila Mencher is in Kingsbridge Heights-Van Cortlandt Village, Bronx.
Premium Details

Get the complete picture

Motley pulls together data from across New York City so you don’t have to. One free account, every school.

Data from 15+ NYC agencies on every school
Personalized school matching for your family
Save schools and build your research board
Sign In — It’s Free

No credit card required

Get all this when you sign in

Survey data, program listings, admissions stats, and the full editorial profile — free, no credit card.

Full School Profile

Skip the tour guessing game. Get the standout features, honest trade-offs, and whether your kid will actually thrive here — before you visit.

Survey Results

See what 2,600+ schools’ own families and teachers really think — trust, safety, instruction quality — so you walk in with the truth, not the brochure.

Programs & Activities

Stop Googling program lists. AP courses, STEM labs, dual-language tracks, sports teams, arts — all categorized so you can compare schools in minutes.

Admissions Demand

Know your odds before you apply. Apps-per-seat ratios, offer rates, and fill data — so you don’t waste your top choice on a long shot.

Economic Need & Special Populations

Find out if the support your child needs is actually there — IEP enrollment, economic need index, and the demographics no other site surfaces.

Discipline

One bad year doesn’t tell you much. Three years of state-verified suspension data shows whether things are getting better or worse.

Sign In — It’s Free