Motley
District 1111
PublicDistrict 11Ed. Opt.

Pelham Preparatory Academy

925 ASTOR AVENUE

At a Glance

A high-demand, low-suspension Bronx high school where families report near-universal satisfaction and students have access to an unusually rich slate of extracurriculars

Best suited for

Families seeking a high-engagement, high-trust high school environment in the Bronx who value culture and climate over tested academic outcomes. Parents comfortable with a neighborhood that has real safety considerations but strong community stability. Families whose students would benefit from extensive extracurricular options — particularly arts and sports — and who want a school where parent voices are clearly heard and valued. The 3.1% acceptance rate means this is a sought-after option, but unlike screened schools, admission is by lottery within the zone, making it accessible to families who don't have test prep resources.

What stands out
  • Extraordinarily high family satisfaction (99%) and principal trust (100%) — both far exceeding district averages
  • Zero suspensions reported, compared to a district average of about 0.5%
  • Extremely competitive admissions (3.1% offer rate) despite being unscreened — indicating strong reputational pull
  • Exceptionally rich extracurricular offerings (90/100 program richness score) including arts, 15+ sports, and diverse clubs
  • Strong teacher-reported instruction quality (95%)
Things to consider
  • No academic test score data available, making it difficult to assess college readiness outcomes
  • The neighborhood has very low safety scores and elevated environmental health concerns (asthma rates, lead exposure)
  • 76.8% economic need index means many students face significant home challenges
  • The school serves a high-poverty population but may not have the resources of wealthier counterparts
  • Limited neighborhood amenities for families compared to other parts of the Bronx

Based on 2025 data

School SummaryDistrict 11

Among district peer schools, Pelham Preparatory Academy does not appear on the top-performing charter school list (which includes Icahn Charter School 4 at 96/100 and Bronx Charter School for Excellence 2 at 94/100). However, the school occupies a distinct niche — it is a district/zoned high school with unscreened admissions that has nonetheless achieved cult-like family loyalty and almost no disciplinary incidents. The survey metrics rival or exceed those of the highest-performing charter peers, suggesting strong leadership and community fit, even if traditional academic metrics are unknown.

AcademicsLimited data

Test score data was not provided in the available dataset, so a direct academic performance comparison to district averages is not possible. However, the school offers AP Courses and a Humanities program, indicating some college-preparatory infrastructure. The average class size of 23.8 matches the district average exactly, suggesting typical staffing levels.

Culturestrong

The survey data paints an exceptionally positive picture of school culture. Parents report 99% satisfaction — well above the district average of 93% — and nearly universal trust in both teachers (99%) and the principal (100%). Teachers themselves rate instruction quality at 95%, also surpassing the district average of 92%. Perhaps most notably, there were zero suspensions in the most recent reporting period, compared to a district average suspension rate of about 0.5%. This suggests either exceptionally effective behavioral approaches or a very different student-teacher dynamic than typical district schools. Teacher-principal trust (89%) and collegial trust (90%) are solid though slightly lower than family trust metrics, indicating some professional tensions that don't necessarily spill over into the classroom experience.

Community

The school serves 496 students in a predominantly Hispanic (53%) and Black (29%) community, with smaller Asian (8%), White (7%), and Multi-Racial (1%) populations. A quarter of students have IEPs, and the economic need index of 76.8% indicates significant student hardship — well above typical district averages. The diversity index of 66% reflects a multicultural student body typical of the Bronx. The neighborhood itself has only 15.5% households with children and a 20.6% BA+ education rate, suggesting many families may be first-generation American or working-class.

NeighborhoodAllerton

Allerton is a stable but resource-limited Bronx neighborhood. The safety score of 11.88 (very low percentile) and high crime density indicate real safety concerns that parents should factor into their calculus. Transit access is moderate (55.94 percentile), making the school accessible by bus and subway. However, the education orientation score of just 41 and low homeownership rate (15.9%) suggest this is not a traditionally "school-choice" oriented community. The area has high stability (83.91 percentile) and family density (72.8 percentile), meaning the neighborhood feels residential and established, even if it lacks the enrichment options of wealthier areas.

Allerton is generally walkable, though the low safety score means families should consider transportation logistics carefully. Students from across the Bronx compete for seats here, so many families commute — the moderate transit score means bus and subway access is feasible but may require significant travel time.

Survey Results

Family Feedback
Satisfaction
99%
Teacher Trust
99%
Principal Trust
100%
Teacher Perspective
Instruction
95%
Principal Trust
89%
Collegial Trust
90%

NYC School Survey (2025) · 272 families responded (63% rate)

Programs & Activities

Academic(2)
AP CoursesHumanities
Arts(4)
Concert And Jazz BandOpening Act Improv TheaterPartnership With AmnhVisual Arts Club
Sports(17)
BaseballBasketballBasketball ClubBowlingCheerleadingCross CountryFootballGymnasticsIndoor TrackJiu-JitzuLacrosseOutdoor TrackRising Ny Road RunnersSoccerSoftballTennisVolleyball
Language(2)
ELL SupportSpanish
Clubs & Activities(17)
BeginnerBrown University And Fordham University Through Gear UpCfes Mentoring ProgramChess ClubCooking ClubEnlaceGaming ClubIntermediateInternational Trip ClubJiu-JitsuNational Honor Society And Spanish Honor SocietyPanther PressPbisRising Ny Road RunnersSat PreparationShakespeare And Songwriting ProgramStudent Council

Admissions Demand

Pelham Preparatory AcademyHighly Competitive

A High School with a College View, focusing on college preparatory experiences and high expectations for achievement. Promoting an intellectually-engaging learning environment, our teachers and staff work closely with students and families to support social and emotional learning, aligned to rigorous academic standards while cultivating literacy skills. Our partner, the University of Vermont, works closely with 9th graders by providing exposure to college applications and essay-writing process.

Seats94
Applicants2,986
Apps/Seat31.8
Offer Rate3.1%

Racial & Ethnic Diversity

Diverse
53%Hispanic/Latino
29%Black
7%White
8%Asian
2%Native American

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Economic Need & Special Populations

Economic Need Index
76.8%
IEP Students
25.8%

Discipline

0suspensions

NYSED Student & Educator Database

Frequently Asked Questions
Is Pelham Preparatory Academy a good school?
Published quality ratings aren't available for Pelham Preparatory Academy yet on Motley. It's a public school serving grades 9 to 12 in Allerton.
What grades does Pelham Preparatory Academy serve?
Pelham Preparatory Academy serves grades 9 to 12.
How do students get into Pelham Preparatory Academy?
Pelham Preparatory Academy uses the Educational Option (Ed-Opt) method, ranking applicants across performance levels so seats go to a mix of abilities.
Is Pelham Preparatory Academy public, charter, or private?
Pelham Preparatory Academy is a public school in NYC Community School District 11.
What neighborhood is Pelham Preparatory Academy in?
Pelham Preparatory Academy is in Allerton, Bronx.
Premium Details

Get the complete picture

Motley pulls together data from across New York City so you don’t have to. One free account, every school.

Data from 15+ NYC agencies on every school
Personalized school matching for your family
Save schools and build your research board
Sign In — It’s Free

No credit card required

Get all this when you sign in

Survey data, program listings, admissions stats, and the full editorial profile — free, no credit card.

Full School Profile

Skip the tour guessing game. Get the standout features, honest trade-offs, and whether your kid will actually thrive here — before you visit.

Survey Results

See what 2,600+ schools’ own families and teachers really think — trust, safety, instruction quality — so you walk in with the truth, not the brochure.

Programs & Activities

Stop Googling program lists. AP courses, STEM labs, dual-language tracks, sports teams, arts — all categorized so you can compare schools in minutes.

Admissions Demand

Know your odds before you apply. Apps-per-seat ratios, offer rates, and fill data — so you don’t waste your top choice on a long shot.

Economic Need & Special Populations

Find out if the support your child needs is actually there — IEP enrollment, economic need index, and the demographics no other site surfaces.

Discipline

One bad year doesn’t tell you much. Three years of state-verified suspension data shows whether things are getting better or worse.

Sign In — It’s Free