At a Glance
A parish-rooted Catholic elementary school where faith formation and academics go hand in hand
Best suited for
Catholic families in southern Brooklyn who want faith-based elementary education at a tuition far below the independent school range, and who appreciate a principal-led, community-rooted school over a more corporate secular environment.
What stands out
- STEM Lab offers hands-on science and engineering exposure unusual for a Catholic elementary at this price point
- Dedicated Learning Center provides in-school academic support for students who need it
- Principal Ms. Competello is repeatedly singled out by name in parent reviews, which is a meaningful signal at a small school
- Cognia accreditation gives the school a recognized credential beyond its Catholic identity
- After School Program supports working families who need coverage past dismissal
Things to consider
- Tuition spans $5,900 to $16,100 - a very wide range that often reflects parishioner vs. non-parishioner rates, so families should ask specifically what they would pay
- Some parent reviews flag classroom behavior management as inconsistent, which is worth investigating on a tour
- School ends at 5th grade - families will need a separate middle school plan in three to six years
- Catholic identity is central; this won't fit a family looking for secular or progressive elementary education
- Parent sentiment is genuinely mixed across platforms—reviews on one platform read more cautious than those on another, so visit with questions ready
Identity
A parish-based Catholic academy that frames its work around Christian values, academic excellence, and developing students who will use their gifts in service to others. It is a faith-forward school, not a secular progressive one - chapel, religious instruction, and moral formation are central to the identity.
Community
The school draws from the surrounding parish and the broader Midwood neighborhood. Parent reviews are mostly warm, with frequent praise for teachers and the principal, Ms. Competello, who is mentioned by name as a steady presence. Some families raise concerns about classroom behavior management, which is a common theme in parent feedback at elementary schools of every kind.
Neighborhood
The school sits on Bay Parkway in the Mapleton-Midwood area, a residential stretch of southern Brooklyn with a mix of single-family homes and small apartment buildings. The neighborhood skews working- and middle-class, with a meaningful share of households living near or below the poverty line and a college-degree rate in the mid-30s - a place where families stretch to afford private school but many still choose it.
The school is genuinely walkable for locals and well-served by transit. The N train at Bay Parkway is about a 7-minute walk, the N at 20th Avenue is around 6 minutes, and the F at Avenue N is also about 6 minutes - unusual coverage that makes drop-off from several directions easy.
Notable Programs
What Parents Are Saying
Mixed reviews - rated 3.7/5 with parents praising excellent teaching staff and principal Ms. Competello, though some express concerns about classroom behavior management; rated 5/5 with highly positive feedback
Synthesized from public parent reviews · Apr 2026
Make this school part of your plan
Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.
No credit card required
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY a good school?
- Published quality ratings aren't available for ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY yet on Motley. It's a private school serving grades Pre-K to 5 in Mapleton-Midwood (West).
- What grades does ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY serve?
- ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY serves grades Pre-K to 5.
- How do students get into ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY?
- ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY runs its own private admissions process — typically an application, a visit, and sometimes testing.
- Is ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY public, charter, or private?
- ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY is a private school.
- What neighborhood is ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY in?
- ST ATHANASIUS CATHOLIC ACADEMY is in Mapleton-Midwood (West), Brooklyn.