At a Glance
A working-class Bronx Catholic school holding fast to prayer, work, and a college-bound mission.
Best suited for
Catholic families in the eastern Bronx — especially working- and middle-class households who want an affordable, faith-centered elementary education with real academic rigor and don't mind a car-dependent commute.
What stands out
- Sliding-scale tuition running from roughly $2,300 to $7,700 — an unusually wide range that makes Catholic education accessible to families across incomes.
- Dual Benedictine and Augustinian heritage, a relatively rare combination that marries contemplative discipline with intellectual tradition.
- Title I-funded literacy and math support inside a private Catholic school, meaning federal resources flow into supplemental academic help for students who need it.
- Italian language instruction — a nod to the neighborhood's cultural roots and a meaningful enrichment offering at the elementary level.
- National Junior Honor Society chapter, signaling an academic culture that recognizes and rewards student achievement.
Things to consider
- The 19.5:1 student-teacher ratio is on the higher end for a Catholic elementary — classes are noticeably bigger than at many peer schools.
- Only one subway line serves the area, and it's a 20-minute walk from the school, so commuting without a car requires real planning.
- Parent reviews are mostly positive but include recurring concerns about teacher favoritism and discipline consistency, so it's worth asking current families pointed questions.
- This is a faith-centered school — families who aren't comfortable with daily religious instruction and Catholic formation should look elsewhere.
- Lower tuition likely means more modest facilities and extracurriculars than pricier Manhattan or Riverdale alternatives.
Identity
Coed Catholic elementary serving PK through grade 5 under the spiritual guidance of two religious traditions — Benedictine prayer-and-work and Augustinian charity-and-knowledge. The school frames its mission around forming "college-bound" students and develops the whole child spiritually, academically, and socially.
Community
The student body is predominantly Hispanic (about 59%), with a meaningful White population (around 23%) and a growing multiracial contingent. The community reflects the surrounding Throgs Neck neighborhood and includes many working- and middle-class families benefiting from the school's wide tuition range.
Neighborhood
The school sits in Throgs Neck-Schuylerville, a middle-income Bronx neighborhood where median household income is around $85,000 and about 15% of residents live in poverty. Roughly a quarter of neighborhood adults hold a bachelor's degree, and the area retains the Italian-American and working-class Catholic character that gives the school its cultural flavor — Italian is even offered as a subject.
Getting here without a car is tough — the nearest subway is the 6 train at Middletown Road, and it's about a 20-minute walk, so most families likely drive or take the bus.
Notable Programs
What Parents Are Saying
Mixed reviews - many praise the school as the best Catholic school in the Bronx with an amazing principal (Ray Vitiello), strong academics, and nurturing family environment; some negative reviews cite teacher favoritism, strict gym teacher, and concerns about student treatment
Synthesized from public parent reviews · Apr 2026
Make this school part of your plan
Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.
No credit card required
Explore nearby
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is ST BENEDICT SCHOOL a good school?
- Published quality ratings aren't available for ST BENEDICT SCHOOL yet on Motley. It's a private school serving grades Pre-K to 5 in Throgs Neck-Schuylerville.
- What grades does ST BENEDICT SCHOOL serve?
- ST BENEDICT SCHOOL serves grades Pre-K to 5.
- How do students get into ST BENEDICT SCHOOL?
- ST BENEDICT SCHOOL runs its own private admissions process — typically an application, a visit, and sometimes testing.
- Is ST BENEDICT SCHOOL public, charter, or private?
- ST BENEDICT SCHOOL is a private school.
- What neighborhood is ST BENEDICT SCHOOL in?
- ST BENEDICT SCHOOL is in Throgs Neck-Schuylerville, Bronx.