At a Glance
A Catholic-founded boys' school weaving classical rigor, spiritual formation, and a museum-rich Manhattan into the elementary years.
Best suited for
Families raising a young boy who want a classically rigorous, character-forward elementary education with deep ties to New York's cultural institutions — and who are comfortable with, or drawn to, the school's Catholic intellectual tradition.
What stands out
- Signature Learning Experiences turn the Met, Guggenheim, American Museum of Natural History, and New-York Historical Society into recurring classroom partners — not one-off field trips.
- Immersive Spanish runs from PK through 5th grade, giving boys roughly nine continuous years of language instruction at a time when many elementary schools offer far less.
- A Digital Universe Field Study pairs students with astrophysicists, and a partnership-supported DNA study brings real science into the elementary science block.
- The classical framing — academics deliberately balanced with athletics, the arts, and spirituality — keeps the boys' school identity from drifting into a one-dimensional prep-everything atmosphere.
- The school's Catholic roots are present without being heavy-handed, with moral and spiritual formation built into the curriculum across grade levels.
Things to consider
- Tuition spans $42,600 to $64,000 for 2025–26 — a notably wide range that usually reflects grade-by-grade pricing, so pin down the figure for your son's specific year.
- This is a boys-only school through 5th grade, which is a real fit decision and not something to gloss over.
- The Catholic foundation is part of the school's identity; families outside that tradition should expect a faith-inflected culture, even if the school describes itself as welcoming broadly.
- Several parent reviewers have flagged concerns about diversity and inclusivity — visit and ask current families directly about how that plays out in daily life.
- The December 1 application deadline is firm; if St. David's is a serious contender, plan tours and references well in advance.
Identity
A Catholic-founded, all-boys elementary school grounded in classical education, blending rigorous academics, athletics, the arts, and spiritual formation into the school day from PK through 5th grade. The mission explicitly calls for educating boys to fulfill their potential through deliberate moral introspection and critical analysis of ideas, not just college-prep polish. Founded in 1951 by nine Catholic families, the school remains rooted in that tradition while reaching outward to New York's cultural institutions.
Community
Parent sentiment paints a picture of a close, welcoming community where teachers are seen as genuinely invested in each boy. The school draws from an affluent Upper East Side catchment — Carnegie Hill's census profile (median household income near $198K, 84% of adults holding a bachelor's degree) suggests a fairly homogeneous, well-resourced parent body. Several reviewers have raised concerns about diversity and inclusivity, which is worth weighing honestly if those values matter to your family.
Neighborhood
Carnegie Hill is one of Manhattan's most family-dense and culturally rich pockets — Museum Mile runs right through it, the side streets are leafy and quiet, and the parents you'll meet at pickup tend to be well-educated professionals. Household incomes here are high and the poverty rate is low, so the area reads as stable and well-resourced. It feels more like a neighborhood than a thoroughfare, which is part of why so many families with young children settle here.
Subway access is solid for an Upper East Side address: the 86 St 4/5/6 station is about a 6-minute walk, the 96 St 6 is roughly 9 minutes, and the 86 St Q is around 10 minutes.
Notable Programs
What Parents Are Saying
Mixed reviews - positive mentions of welcoming community, academic challenge, and supportive faculty; negative comments regarding lack of diversity and inclusivity concerns
Synthesized from public parent reviews · Apr 2026
Make this school part of your plan
Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.
No credit card required
Explore nearby
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is ST DAVIDS SCHOOL a good school?
- Published quality ratings aren't available for ST DAVIDS SCHOOL yet on Motley. It's a private school serving grades Pre-K to 5 in Upper East Side-Carnegie Hill.
- What grades does ST DAVIDS SCHOOL serve?
- ST DAVIDS SCHOOL serves grades Pre-K to 5.
- How do students get into ST DAVIDS SCHOOL?
- ST DAVIDS SCHOOL runs its own private admissions process — typically an application, a visit, and sometimes testing.
- Is ST DAVIDS SCHOOL public, charter, or private?
- ST DAVIDS SCHOOL is a private school.
- What neighborhood is ST DAVIDS SCHOOL in?
- ST DAVIDS SCHOOL is in Upper East Side-Carnegie Hill, Manhattan.