At a Glance
An affordable, Christ-centered elementary school on Staten Island — small by design, rooted in Lutheran tradition
Families on Staten Island seeking an affordable, faith-based elementary education with small classes and a nurturing environment. Particularly well-matched for parents who prioritize moral values, religious instruction, and personal attention over academic competitiveness — and who don't mind a traditional disciplinary approach. Families should have transportation, as this neighborhood is not walkable to transit.
- Tuition of $3,633–$5,838 makes this one of the most affordable private schools in New York City
- Free Pre-K For All program brings high-quality early childhood education at no cost
- Very small class sizes — typically one classroom per grade means individualized attention
- Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod accreditation provides structured, values-based framework
- On-site music lessons and extracurriculars like Lego Fun and Jr. High Youth Group
- Academic rigor is described as moderate — some parents feel it lags behind more competitive schools
- Discipline approach is traditional and structured, which may feel strict for some families
- No middle school (only through grade 5) — you'll need to plan for a transition after fifth grade
- Staten Island location requires a car for most families; limited transit options
- Mixed online reviews suggest the experience can depend heavily on classroom fit
A small, church-affiliated school with roughly one class per grade, anchored in Christian values and personalized attention. This is a school where your child will be known by name — but the academic intensity varies compared to more rigorous secular or independent schools.
Parents who choose St. John's typically value the tight-knit, family-like atmosphere over academic competitiveness. Online reviews highlight caring teachers who know students well, but also note some families have felt the academic rigor could be stronger and the disciplinary approach quite strict.
Westerleigh-Castleton Corners is a quiet, residential section of Staten Island with single-family homes, tree-lined streets, and a family-oriented feel. It's convenient to the Staten Island Expressway and not far from the North Shore — but this is car-dependent territory, so factor in commute time if you're coming from elsewhere on the island or by ferry.
This is a driving neighborhood. The nearest Staten Island Railway station is several blocks away, and the area's layout favors cars over pedestrians. If transit access matters to your family, this is worth considering.
Notable Programs
What Parents Are Saying
Mixed reviews: Parents praise caring teachers, small class sizes, loving environment; some criticize low academic rigor and strict disciplinary approaches
Synthesized from public parent reviews · Apr 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL a good school?
- Published quality ratings aren't available for ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL yet on Motley. It's a private school serving grades Pre-K to 5 in Westerleigh-Castleton Corners.
- What grades does ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL serve?
- ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL serves grades Pre-K to 5.
- How do students get into ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL?
- ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL runs its own private admissions process — typically an application, a visit, and sometimes testing.
- Is ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL public, charter, or private?
- ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL is a private school.
- What neighborhood is ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL in?
- ST JOHN'S LUTHERAN SCHOOL is in Westerleigh-Castleton Corners, Staten Island.
Get the complete picture
Motley pulls together data from across New York City so you don’t have to. One free account, every school.
No credit card required
Get all this when you sign in
Survey data, program listings, admissions stats, and the full editorial profile — free, no credit card.
Full School Profile
Skip the tour guessing game. Get the standout features, honest trade-offs, and whether your kid will actually thrive here — before you visit.
Survey Results
See what 2,600+ schools’ own families and teachers really think — trust, safety, instruction quality — so you walk in with the truth, not the brochure.
Programs & Activities
Stop Googling program lists. AP courses, STEM labs, dual-language tracks, sports teams, arts — all categorized so you can compare schools in minutes.
Admissions Demand
Know your odds before you apply. Apps-per-seat ratios, offer rates, and fill data — so you don’t waste your top choice on a long shot.
Economic Need & Special Populations
Find out if the support your child needs is actually there — IEP enrollment, economic need index, and the demographics no other site surfaces.
Discipline
One bad year doesn’t tell you much. Three years of state-verified suspension data shows whether things are getting better or worse.