At a Glance
A parish Catholic school where RICH values, the whole child, and a remarkably diverse student body share the front of the classroom.
Best suited for
Catholic or values-driven Queens families looking for a diverse, whole-child elementary with strong arts and a free Pre-K entry point, who can handle a longer commute.
What stands out
- Participates in NYC's Pre-K For All, offering free full-day Pre-K — a real cost-saver that makes the parish school's early grades unusually accessible.
- The "RICH values" framework is built into the school's stated identity rather than buried in a mission statement, giving parents a concrete vocabulary for the culture.
- An unusually broad fine-arts program for an elementary, spanning art, choir, drama, music, and notably ballroom dancing.
- Foundational Spanish begins in the elementary years, giving students early exposure to a second language.
- An extended-day program offers before- and after-school coverage for working families.
Things to consider
- Catholic identity is woven into the school day — families should expect religion to be part of curriculum and culture, not an elective.
- The 17.5:1 student-teacher ratio is in a typical range for parish schools — personal, but not the small-class boutique experience some progressive schools offer.
- No subway within easy walking distance of the youngest students; the commute should be a real factor for car-free families, especially in winter.
- Open and ongoing admissions means flexibility, but families used to a formal admissions season should expect to apply rather than simply enroll.
- With 278 students across PK–5, this is a full, lively elementary — not a small intimate cohort.
Identity
A coed Catholic elementary school serving Pre-K through 5th grade under the Diocese of Brooklyn, anchored in a "RICH values" framework — Respect, Integrity, Charity, and Helpfulness — and a whole-child philosophy that pairs faith formation with academics, arts, and athletics. The school draws its character as much from its parish roots as from its explicit commitment to developing students spiritually, academically, socially, emotionally, and physically.
Community
At 278 students, this is a mid-sized Catholic elementary with a genuinely mixed student body: roughly 43% Hispanic, 23% Asian, 19% Black, and 13% White, giving it a diversity index well above the city private-school average. That mix tracks closely with the surrounding Queens neighborhood rather than the more homogeneous profile of many parish schools. It reads less as an institution serving one cultural community and more as a Queens-wide elementary that happens to be Catholic.
Neighborhood
Kew Gardens Hills is a middle-income Queens neighborhood where nearly half of adults hold a bachelor's degree and household incomes cluster around the mid-$80,000s — a comfortable, family-oriented pocket of eastern Queens. The schools and streets here reflect the borough's patchwork of immigrant and multigenerational American families, with synagogues, churches, and longtime local businesses sharing the same blocks. It's the kind of place where parents tend to know each other through the parish and the playground.
The nearest subway is Parsons Blvd on the F line, about a 17-minute walk, with Sutphin Blvd (F) and Briarwood (E, F) each roughly 19 minutes on foot — long walks for young children, so most families will likely rely on a car, school bus, or local bus for the daily commute.
Notable Programs
What Parents Are Saying
A 4.1 rating from 63 reviews indicates generally positive sentiment
Synthesized from public parent reviews · Apr 2026
Make this school part of your plan
Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.
No credit card required
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC a good school?
- Published quality ratings aren't available for ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC yet on Motley. It's a private school serving grades Pre-K to 5 in Kew Gardens Hills.
- What grades does ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC serve?
- ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC serves grades Pre-K to 5.
- How do students get into ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC?
- ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC runs its own private admissions process — typically an application, a visit, and sometimes testing.
- Is ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC public, charter, or private?
- ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC is a private school.
- What neighborhood is ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC in?
- ST NICHOLAS OF TOLENTINE CATHOLIC is in Kew Gardens Hills, Queens.