Motley

Best Elementary Schools in Madison

The top elementary schools in Madison, ranked by our overall rating — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. P.S. 255 Barbara Reing School leads with 70/100. 9 elementary schools in Madison in total.

The ranking

1
P.S. 255 Barbara Reing School1866 East 17 Street
  • K–5 Elementary
2
Bnos Israel Of East Flatbush1629 EAST 15 STREET
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
Not rated
3
Good Shepherd Catholic Academy1943 BROWN STREET
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
Not rated
4
Prospect Park Bnos Leah High Sch1601 AVENUE R
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 9–12 High School
Not rated
5
Reach For The Stars Learning Center1818 AVENUE P
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
Not rated
6
St Edmund Elementary School1902 AVENUE T
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
Not rated
7
Yeshiva Derech Hatorah2810 NOSTRAND AVENUE
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
Not rated
8
Bnos Esther Malka1784 EAST 17 STREET
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
Not rated
9
Yeshivat Ohel Torah2600 OCEAN AVENUE
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
Not rated
How this is scored→
Browse all best-school lists →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best elementary school in Madison?
P.S. 255 Barbara Reing School ranks highest by our overall rating (70/100). The best fit depends on your child — Smart Match (Motley Pro) ranks schools against your family's priorities.
How many elementary schools are in Madison?
There are 9 elementary schools in Madison.
How are these schools ranked?
By our overall rating — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. The Approaching / Meeting / Exceeding bands are our thresholds, not New York State levels. Smart Match (Motley Pro) weighs academics, diversity, programs, distance from home, and special-education needs against your family's priorities.

Which of these fits your child?

Smart Match (Motley Pro) ranks the schools in your area against your family's priorities — academics, distance from home, diversity, programs, and special-education needs.

Find the right fit →