New Dorp-Midland Beach vs Tottenville-Charleston
New Dorp-Midland Beach (Staten Island) and Tottenville-Charleston (Staten Island), compared across the nine signals we score for families. New Dorp-Midland Beach scores higher on Activities and Neighborhood Character; Tottenville-Charleston leads on Schools and Families. Overall they're 85% similar on family fit.
How they compare
| Metric | New Dorp-Midland Beach | Tottenville-Charleston |
|---|---|---|
| Family Fit | 59/100 | 66/100 (leads) |
| Families | 10/100 | 19/100 (leads) |
| Affordability | 93/100 | 94/100 (leads) |
| Schools | 64/100 | 91/100 (leads) |
| Neighborhood Character | 13/100 (leads) | 1/100 |
| Transit | 8/100 (leads) | 0/100 |
| Safety | 81/100 (leads) | 79/100 |
| Health | 94/100 | 100/100 (leads) |
| Activities | 32/100 (leads) | 1/100 |
Weekday-morning commute
| Metric | New Dorp-Midland Beach | Tottenville-Charleston |
|---|---|---|
| To Midtown | 77–78 min (leads) | 100–106 min |
| To Lower Manhattan | 61–62 min (leads) | 92–95 min |
| To Hudson Yards | 83–84 min (leads) | 106–111 min |
| To Union Square / Flatiron | 73–74 min (leads) | 103–107 min |
| To Upper East Side medical corridor | 87–88 min (leads) | 115–119 min |
| To Downtown Brooklyn | 66–67 min (leads) | 97–100 min |
| To Long Island City | 81–83 min (leads) | 107–111 min |
| To Jamaica | 105–107 min (leads) | 2 h+ |
| To Flushing | 107–109 min (leads) | 2 h+ |
| To Fordham | 103–107 min (leads) | 2 h+ |
Typical transit and walking time, leaving between 7:30 and 9:00 a.m. on a weekday, from each neighborhood's population center; the shorter trip leads. From MTA, NYC DOT and NYC Ferry schedules, so no delays or crowding. Streets © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is New Dorp-Midland Beach or Tottenville-Charleston better for families?
- New Dorp-Midland Beach and Tottenville-Charleston each suit different families. New Dorp-Midland Beach leads on Activities, Neighborhood Character, and Transit, while Tottenville-Charleston leads on Schools, Families, and Family Fit. What's "better" depends on what you prioritize — safety, schools, affordability, or transit. Our neighborhood search can rank them by your own weights.
- How do New Dorp-Midland Beach and Tottenville-Charleston compare on safety and schools?
- New Dorp-Midland Beach: 81/100 safety, 64/100 schools. Tottenville-Charleston: 79/100 safety, 91/100 schools.
- Are New Dorp-Midland Beach and Tottenville-Charleston similar neighborhoods?
- They're 85% similar across the nine signals we score. New Dorp-Midland Beach stands out on Activities, Neighborhood Character, and Transit.
Which neighborhood fits your family?
Our neighborhood search ranks the 197 residential NYC neighborhoods by your own weights — safety, schools, affordability, transit, and more. Free, no account needed.
Rank neighborhoods for my family →