Motley
Bensonhurst, Brooklyn

Bensonhurst

At A Glance

Bensonhurst is a large residential neighborhood with strong Chinese and Italian communities. Affordable housing and local retail serve a growing family population.

Did you know?

Bensonhurst's 18th Avenue Feast of Santa Rosalia has been celebrating Sicilian heritage with a street festival every September since 1903.

Want personalized insights for your family?

Get an agentic neighborhood analysis — including safety and cost of living — tailored to your priorities, family size, budget, and commute.

Analyze for My Family

Places of Interest

Neighborhood Stats

33Schools
3Parks & Playgrounds
7Subway Lines
100Restaurants
29Groceries
37Coffee Shops

Avg Rent

$2,300per month
Updated Apr 2026

Avg Sale Price

$1.24Mmedian sale

$668 / sq ft

Updated Apr 2026

Top-rated schools

Who’s your neighbor?

$65KMedian Income
21%Under 18
31%College+
32%Own Their Home

What families should know

Schools

33

Bensonhurst runs deep on school options, with two dozen public schools anchoring the neighborhood alongside a solid roster of private schools and one charter. New Utrecht High School on 80th Street is the neighborhood's main public high school, feeding into J.H.S. 227 Edward B. Shallow on 16th Avenue for middle schoolers, and several P.S. elementary options scattered across the blocks. Private school families have choices like Magen David Yeshivah and Bais Esther, while the Success Academy charter adds another pathway. It's a genuine mix — not every block has a zoned option, but the spread means most families can find something that fits.

Early Education

34
Shalva UPK I1462 62 Street
View
65Th Street Daycare Inc1502 West 1 Street
2 years – 5 yearsView
0 years – 2 yearsView
Kings Pointe Talent Inc.1457 West 5 Street
2 years – 5 yearsView
2 years – 5 yearsView
LITTLE SUNSHINE INC.1815 85 STREET
2 years – 5 yearsView
2 years – 5 yearsView
2 years – 5 yearsView
DREAMLAND DAY CARE INC.1379 WEST 7 STREET
2 years – 5 yearsView
GENERATION21 NY, INC6709 19 AVENUE
0 years – 16 yearsView
Happy Scholars, Inc.2157336 New Utrecht Avenue
View
2 years – 5 yearsView
2 years – 5 yearsView
2 years – 5 yearsView
0 years – 16 yearsView
Generation21 Day Care6709 19 Avenue
2 years – 5 yearsView
Kindstart Preschool7702 New Utrecht Avenue
2 years – 5 yearsView
Browse all early-ed in this neighborhood

Parks & Playgrounds

3
Nearest large park: Dyker Beach Park · ~25 min walk (1 mi)

Bensonhurst offers a tight cluster of three solid playgrounds scattered through the residential blocks. Garibaldi Playground and Seth Low Playground/Bealin Square anchor the north and south ends, while Lt. Joseph Petrosino Park covers the middle ground. It's not a park-heavy neighborhood in the sense of big green acres, but these three give families decent options for afternoon play within walking distance. The selection is modest but reliable.

Transportation

54

Getting around Bensonhurst means living along the D and N lines, with stops scattered from 18 Av up through 79 St on the D and Bay Pkwy on the N. The D gives you a straight shot into Midtown and Downtown Brooklyn, while the N cuts through the neighborhood's spine before merging at DeKalb. It's a solid, no-nonsense setup for commuters — you're not close to Manhattan, but the trains run frequently and the bus network along 86th Street and Bay Parkway fills in the gaps for local runs.

Restaurants

100

The food scene here is quintessentially residential — a deep bench of delis, bakeries, and quick-take spots rather than a destination dining strip. The Asian selection surprises: Korean fried chicken and hot pot clusters around 86th Street, solid Chinese and Hong Kong cafe options along 18th Avenue, and a growing sushi presence. Italian pizza and pasta holds it down on the western end near New Utrecht, while dessert joints — crepe spots, bubble tea, and a couple of Carvels — keep the kids happy. When you need a chain fix, there's a Chipotle and a few Burger Kings, but Bensonhurst runs on its small, independently-owned spots.

Groceries

29

Bensonhurst's grocery scene is surprisingly deep — you won't need to trek far for a full weekly shop. A solid bench of ethnic markets lines Bay Parkway and 86th Street, with several Asian supermarkets stocking everything from fresh dim sum ingredients to hard-to-find produce. For the familiar chains, there's a Key Food, a couple of CTowns, and a Met Food handling your standard American staples. The variety is excellent — specialty shops for seafood, meats, and produce dot the commercial strips. You'll likely need a car for the big haul, but smaller trips are transit-friendly.

Coffee Shops

37

Bensonhurst coffee culture runs deep along the 18th Ave and 86th St corridors, where you'll find a solid mix of the familiar and the hyper-specific. Two Starbucks and a pair of Dunkin' anchor the main drags for reliable, no-surprises morning runs, but the real character comes from the Italian caffes pulling shots alongside spots like Kung Fu Tea and multiple bubble tea options. It's less third-wave hangout and more functional caffeine network — grab and go or sit with a pastry, depending on the crowd.

Things to Do

35

Bensonhurst's kids' activity scene is heavy on enrichment — especially dance and martial arts, which together make up nearly half the list. Studios like The Little Gym anchor a strong gymnastics and swim options, while music schools and tutoring centers (including the Russian School of Mathematics and Kumon) round out the mix. Sports fans aren't left out either, with soccer academies and a public park offering field space. It's a deep bench for families looking to fill a weekend.

Daycare & informal care

6

Bensonhurst offers a deep bench of childcare and Pre-K options — 21 Pre-K sites spread across the neighborhood alongside about half a dozen daycares. The options lean heavily toward universal Pre-K through the district, with private daycare as the smaller slice. For families with little ones, there's a reasonable spread across the blocks near New Utrecht Ave and the 71st Street corridor, though morning drop-off can get congested on the main drags. The mix means you're likely to find a spot if you plan ahead, but don't wait until the last minute.

Family Resources

4

Bensonhurst's got a solid base of community anchors for families, anchored by a pair of greenmarkets that pop up along 18th Avenue — one between 81st and 82nd Streets, the other at 81st Street. Garibaldi Playground on 18th Avenue and Lt. Joseph Petrosino Park over on 16th Avenue give kids room to run and locals spots to linger. It's a modest setup but well-concentrated, and what they're doing with these public spaces feels genuine to the neighborhood.

Healthcare

24

Bensonhurst has a deep bench of pediatricians and dentists scattered along Bay Parkway and 18th Avenue — families won't travel far for well-child visits or routine cleanings. Urgent care is well-covered too, with a couple of CityMD locations and PM Pediatrics handling after-hours bumps and bruises. The hospital scene is smaller but includes anchors like Brooklyn Comprehensive Care Center and Healthcare Choices NY along Bay Parkway, though some specialized care may mean a ride elsewhere.

Neighborhood map

Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bensonhurst a good neighborhood for families?
Bensonhurst scores 51/100 for families on Motley — near the middle of the pack citywide. The Family Fit score blends safety, schools, parks, cost of living, and community.
Is Bensonhurst safe?
Bensonhurst scores 41/100 on safety — near the middle of the pack citywide. We build the score from NYPD complaint data, normalized by population.
How are the schools in Bensonhurst?
Bensonhurst has 33 schools mapped inside its boundary and scores 68/100 for schools — ahead of most NYC neighborhoods.
Is Bensonhurst affordable?
Bensonhurst scores 29/100 for affordability on Motley — among the pricier parts of the city.
Which borough is Bensonhurst in?
Bensonhurst is a neighborhood in Brooklyn, New York City.

Want personalized insights for your family?

Sign in to get an agentic neighborhood analysis — including safety and cost of living — tailored to your priorities, family size, budget, and commute.