Motley
District 3131
CharterDistrict 31 →Charter Lottery

Early College Charter School

1441 South Avenue

At a Glance

A small Staten Island charter betting big on its college-prep identity, but state-test results haven't kept pace with that ambition.

Best suited for

Families drawn to a small, relationship-driven charter community on Staten Island who are willing to actively supplement math instruction outside school.

Overall Rating

Grades 3–8

29
Not Meeting
Not MeetingApproachingMeetingExceeding
ELA43.5
Math13.8

Rating = average of NY State ELA + math proficiency, grades 3–8

High school

59
Approaching
Not MeetingApproachingMeetingExceeding
4-year graduation96
English Regents 70+31
Regents completion51

Rating = average of 4-year graduation, English Regents college-ready and Regents completion · DOE 2025 report

Bands are Motley's thresholds on a 0–100 scale, not New York State performance levels.

How this is scored→

What stands out

  • Small school with 240 total students, allowing for tighter relationships than typical middle or high schools
  • Charter governance with a dedicated college-prep identity, drawing families who specifically want that mission
  • Parent satisfaction at 96% — among the strongest family-side signals in the data
  • Quarter of students receive IEP services, suggesting dedicated support for students with disabilities

Things to consider

  • Math proficiency of 13.8% is a serious flag — well under half the district average and trending downward recently
  • Chronic absenteeism at 45.5% means nearly half of students are missing significant school time
  • Volatile year-over-year test swings (ELA dropped to 18.4% in 2023 before rebounding) suggest inconsistency rather than steady progress
  • Staten Island has no subway access, so commuting without a car is difficult
  • Family survey response rate was only 10% — the satisfaction figures reflect a small, possibly self-selecting slice of families

Based on 2023-24 data

School SummaryDistrict 31

Within Staten Island's District 31, this school sits well below the district averages across academics and attendance — the district's overall score of 2.45 out of 4 is more than double this school's 1.15. The peer schools listed are all elementary schools, which makes direct comparison awkward, but the gap against district-level averages is hard to ignore.

Academics

Limited data

State-test proficiency here is well below the district average on both measures: ELA at 43.5% trails the district's 61.3%, and math at 13.8% is strikingly behind the district's 61%. The trajectory is bumpy rather than steadily improving — ELA swung from 23.7% in 2019 to 18.4% in 2023 before jumping back to 43.5% in 2024, while math has actually drifted downward over the same period. Given that only Grade 8 test data is reported, it's hard to tell whether older students are progressing or not. The headline math number in particular — sub-15% — is the kind of figure that signals students are entering high school without solid foundations to build on.

Culture

concerning

The families who respond are enthusiastic — 96% parent satisfaction and 91% parent-teacher trust are notably strong, though the response rate of just 10% means these are the voices of the most engaged households, not necessarily everyone. Teacher instruction quality is reported at 84%, below the district average of 93%, and only nine teachers responded, so read that figure with caution. Day-to-day attendance is a worry: 45.5% chronic absenteeism is high, and the overall 85.7% attendance rate sits meaningfully below the district's 91.4%. The trust signals between teachers and leadership look healthier than the academic ones, suggesting a community where relationships are working even if instructional consistency isn't.

Community

The student body is roughly 46% Hispanic, 29% Black, 19% White, and 3% Asian, with an economic need index of 68.9 — meaning most students come from households facing some financial pressure. A quarter of students have IEPs, which is meaningfully higher than typical. The surrounding New Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-Travis neighborhood is comparatively middle-class, with a $98,222 median household income and only 10.5% poverty, so the school draws a more economically diverse mix than its immediate census tract would suggest.

Neighborhood

New Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-Travis

The school sits in New Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-Travis, a part of Staten Island where roughly three-quarters of residents own their homes and median household income clears $98,000 — a solidly middle-class, family-oriented stretch of the borough. About a quarter of households have children, and a third of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher. There's no subway within walking distance, which is unsurprising for Staten Island but means getting here realistically requires a car or school transportation.

The school is beyond walking distance of any subway station, so families will need to rely on a car, school bus, or local bus service to get here.

Academic Performance

ELA Proficiency

43.5%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State ELA exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Math Proficiency

13.8%

Students scoring proficient or above on the NY State Math exam.

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Historical Trends

ELA Math

The dashed line marks 2023, when New York changed its grades 3–8 state tests. Scores before and after it aren’t directly comparable.

2020–2021 data unavailable due to COVID-19

Source: NYC DOE School Quality Reports

Survey Results

Family Feedback
Satisfaction
96%
Teacher Trust
91%
Principal Trust
91%
Relationships
n/a
Teacher Perspective
Instruction
84%
Principal Trust
87%
Collegial Trust
96%
Safety
n/a

NYC School Survey (2025) · 17 families responded (10% rate)

Racial & Ethnic Diversity

Diverse
46%Hispanic/Latino
29%Black
19%White
3%Asian
1%Multi-Racial

NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23

Economic Need & Special Populations

Economic Need Index
68.9%
IEP Students
24.6%
Free account

Make this school part of your plan

Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.

Save this school to a shortlist, next to the neighborhoods you're weighing
Tell us about your family once — grades, priorities, where you live
Get a read on any neighborhood for your family
Ask Motley Intelligence about this school, with your family in mind
Sign In — It’s Free

No credit card required

Compare head-to-head

Explore nearby

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Early College Charter School a good school?
On Motley, Early College Charter School earns an overall rating of 29/100 — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. Its state test results run below the District 31 average. Its high school grades have their own rating, 59/100, from graduation and Regents results.
What grades does Early College Charter School serve?
Early College Charter School serves grades 8 to 12.
How do students get into Early College Charter School?
Early College Charter School is a charter school — it admits through a free public lottery, with no test or attendance zone.
Is Early College Charter School public, charter, or private?
Early College Charter School is a public charter school in NYC Community School District 31.
What neighborhood is Early College Charter School in?
Early College Charter School is in New Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-Travis, Staten Island.