At a Glance
A small Expeditionary Learning high school where teachers trust leadership and suspensions are essentially zero
Best suited for
Staten Island families — or families willing to navigate a car-dependent commute — who want a small, intentionally chosen high school with an Expeditionary Learning model, a humanities focus, and a climate where staff are aligned and discipline isn't an issue. Especially strong fit for families who prioritize school culture and community size over easily measurable test-score rankings, and who are comfortable applying through the ed-opt process rather than relying on a zoned assignment.
Overall Rating
Rating = average of 4-year graduation, English Regents college-ready and Regents completion · DOE 2025 report
Bands are Motley's thresholds on a 0–100 scale, not New York State performance levels.
How this is scored→What stands out
- Zero suspensions reported — essentially no discipline incidents in the data period
- 100% teacher-principal trust, an unusually strong staff-leadership alignment
- Expeditionary Learning model with a Humanities focus and AP coursework
- Program richness score of 100/100, including unusual offerings like fencing, martial arts, fashion club, step, and film club
- Small screened high school of 435 students with an ed-opt admissions process that creates an actively chosen community
Things to consider
- No subway access means families should plan for car or bus commutes, which can be a real barrier for students from other boroughs
- PTA fundraising is extremely low at $4 per student versus a district average of about $141 — the parent-organization engine here is small and that has practical implications for extras and enrichment
- Family survey response rate was only 19%, so parent satisfaction data reflects a vocal slice of families rather than the full parent body
- Standardized proficiency scores aren't available in the data, making academic outcomes harder to evaluate from the numbers alone
- Admissions are competitive — the school had 545 applicants for 82 seats last cycle, an offer rate of about 14%, so getting in requires a strong application
- 25% of students have IEPs, which is a meaningful share and reflects positively on inclusion but means families should look closely at how special education is supported
Based on 2024-25 data
School SummaryDistrict 31
District 31 covers Staten Island, and the peer schools shown in the data are all elementary schools (P.S. 35, Naples Street, P.S. 5, P.S. 8, P.S. 23, P.S. 3) — meaning Gaynor McCown sits in a different band of the district than those comparison points. Against District 31's high school averages, its climate and culture numbers run above the district mean, and its class size matches the district average of 23.4. Where it falls notably below the district is PTA fundraising per student, where $4 trails the district's roughly $141 by a wide margin.
Academics
Standardized test proficiency data isn't shown in the available figures, so a clean academic comparison to the district's roughly 61% ELA and 61% Math averages isn't possible. What stands out from the program side: the school offers AP Courses and a Humanities focus within its Expeditionary Learning model, plus ELL support and Spanish for language learners. Twenty-five percent of students have IEPs, which is meaningful context — special education is a real part of how this school is staffed and scheduled. Class size sits right at the district average of about 23, so students aren't getting smaller cohorts than peers elsewhere in District 31.
Culture
The climate numbers here are the kind you almost never see. Teacher-principal trust is 100%, teacher collegial trust is 98%, and teacher-reported instruction quality is 97% — all above the District 31 averages of roughly 94% and 93%. Parent satisfaction lands at 92%, just a hair below the district average of 93%, and parent-principal trust is 95%. Total suspensions: zero. The day-to-day feel is one where the staff is aligned, families feel reasonably heard, and discipline isn't a flashpoint. One honest caveat: only 19% of families completed the survey and 31 teachers responded, so the climate story is based on a relatively small slice of the school community — the people who did respond are glowing, but the response rate suggests some families aren't being captured.
Community
Gaynor McCown's student body is about half White (50%), with Hispanic students making up 22%, Black students 10%, and Asian students 9%. That mix lines up reasonably well with the surrounding neighborhood, which is largely middle-income and family-oriented — about a quarter of households in the area have children, and the median household income is around $98,000. The school's economic need index is 47.1, meaning roughly half of students are considered economically disadvantaged, somewhat higher than the neighborhood's 10.5% poverty rate would suggest — a reminder that this is a citywide screened school drawing from across Staten Island, not just the immediate blocks.
Neighborhood
The school is in New Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-Travis, a sprawling residential pocket of Staten Island defined by single-family homeownership (76%), a median home value around $641,000, and a population where about a quarter of households include children. The median household income is roughly $98,000 and about 34% of adults have a bachelor's degree or higher — solidly middle-class, family-oriented, and largely car-dependent. With no subway stations within a 20-minute walk, daily life here runs on cars and local buses, which shapes how families connect to the rest of the city.
No subway stations are within a 20-minute walk of the school, so families here rely on driving, school transportation, or local Staten Island buses to get to and from campus
Survey Results
NYC School Survey (2025) · 99 families responded (19% rate)
Programs & Activities
Admissions Demand
Our school partners with NYC Outward Bound Schools and EL Education to offer student-centered learning, focused around case studies and expeditions, that incorporate fieldwork, products presented to authentic audiences, and service learning opportunities. We expect students to uphold our character traits of creativity, honesty, humor, respect, and responsibility. Students are part of a Crew that provides social and emotional support, opportunities for community service and academic tracking.
Racial & Ethnic Diversity
NYC DOE InfoHub · 2022-23
PTA Fundraising
Source: DOE Local Law 171 disclosure
Discipline
NYSED Student & Educator Database
Economic Need & Special Populations
How to get in, step by step
High school (9th grade)
High school is one citywide application, made in 8th grade. Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School admits through one program, and each one has its own admissions method:
- Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning SchoolEd. Opt.
High school application
- Opened
- Tue, Oct 6
- Closes
- Fri, Dec 4
- Offers
- Wed, Mar 3
The DOE’s published dates.
- 1Apply on MySchools during the high school application, in 8th grade.
- 2Educational Option programs fill in equal shares across three reading levels, half by the school's ranking and half by lottery.
- 3Rank programs in true preference order — the match places your child in the highest-ranked one that offers a seat.
Open houses and tours
We haven’t seen open-house dates for this school yet.
From the MySchools admissions calendar, checked weekly.
Make this school part of your plan
Everything on this page is yours to read. An account keeps your research in one place.
No credit card required
Compare head-to-head
Explore nearby
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School a good school?
- On Motley, Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School earns an overall rating of 85/100 — the average of the school's four-year graduation rate, the share of its students scoring college-ready (70+) on the English Regents, and its Regents completion rate, shown out of 100.
- What grades does Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School serve?
- Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School serves grades 9 to 12.
- How do students get into Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School?
- Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School uses the Educational Option (Ed-Opt) method, ranking applicants across performance levels so seats go to a mix of abilities.
- Is Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School public, charter, or private?
- Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School is a public school in NYC Community School District 31.
- What neighborhood is Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School in?
- Gaynor McCown Expeditionary Learning School is in New Springville-Willowbrook-Bulls Head-Travis, Staten Island.