Tottenville High School

The data provided does not include specific proficiency scores for Tottenville High School, making direct academic performance comparisons difficult. However, the school operates within District 31, where average ELA and Math proficiency both hover around 61%. Given the school's selective programs like the Classics Institute (which drew 837 applicants for 56 seats), there appears to be an academic tier within the school that attracts high-achieving students. The lack of visible test score data means parents should inquire directly about academic performance and college outcomes.

The survey data paints a remarkably positive picture of school culture. Parent satisfaction (92%), parent-teacher trust (94%), and parent-principal trust (96%) all indicate families feel heard and valued. Teachers give exceptional marks for instruction quality (98%) and report strong collegial trust (92%), with teacher-principal trust at 90%. Discipline is notably light — just 7 suspensions total, well below the district average suspension rate of 0.44%. This suggests a school where expectations are clear, relationships are strong, and the day-to-day environment feels supportive rather than punitive.

Tottenville draws heavily from its neighborhood demographics: 73% White, 14% Hispanic, 9% Asian, with only 2% Black students. This is a departure from more diverse parts of Staten Island and the city overall (diversity index of 48% versus citywide averages). The economic need index of 36.9% is notably lower than many city schools, reflecting the neighborhood's affluence (median household income $118,500, 79.5% homeownership). About 23% of students have IEPs, aligning with typical citywide rates.

Tottenville sits in one of Staten Island's most family-friendly and safest neighborhoods. The area scores 87.36 for safety, well above city averages, with low crime density. The family density score of 65.52 reflects many households with children. However, transit access is extremely limited (19.92) — this is a car-dependent area, and families should expect driving to be necessary for most commutes. The education orientation score of 68.58 suggests a community that values schools. Home values median at $800,899, indicating a comfortable, established residential neighborhood.

This area is not walkable in the urban sense — the transit score of 19.92 reflects very limited public transportation options. Families will need a car for most daily logistics, and the school draws students from across southern Staten Island.