Motley

Best Middle Schools in Staten Island

The top middle schools in Staten Island, ranked by our overall rating — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. Hellenic Classical Charter School - Staten Island leads with 83/100, followed by I.S. 075 Frank D. Paulo and P.S./I.S. 26 The Carteret School. 26 middle schools in Staten Island in total.

The ranking

1
Hellenic Classical Charter School - Staten Island1641 Richmond Avenue
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
2
I.S. 075 Frank D. Paulo455 HUGUENOT AVENUE
  • 6–8 Middle School
3
P.S./I.S. 26 The Carteret School4108 Victory Boulevard
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
4
I.S. 007 Elias Bernstein1270 Huguenot Avenue
  • 6–8 Middle School
5
I.S. 034 Tottenville528 ACADEMY AVENUE
  • 6–8 Middle School
6
P.S. 048 William G. Wilcox1050 Targee Street
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
7
I.S. 024 Myra S. Barnes750 DURANT AVENUE
  • 6–8 Middle School
8
Staten Island School of Civic Leadership280 REGIS DRIVE
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
9
The Michael J. Petrides School715 Ocean Terrace
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
10
Marsh Avenue School for Expeditionary Learning100 ESSEX DRIVE
  • 6–8 Middle School
11
I.S. 072 Rocco Laurie33 FERNDALE AVENUE
  • 6–8 Middle School
12
New World Preparatory Charter School285 CLOVE ROAD
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
13
I.S. R002 George L. Egbert333 Midland Avenue
  • 6–8 Middle School
14
I.S. 051 Edwin Markham80 WILLOWBROOK ROAD
  • 6–8 Middle School
15
I.S. 027 Anning S. Prall11 Clove Lake Place
  • 6–8 Middle School
16
The Eagle Academy for Young Men of Staten Island101 WARREN STREET
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
17
John W. Lavelle Preparatory Charter School1441 South Avenue
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
18
I.S. 49 Berta A. Dreyfus101 WARREN STREET
  • 6–8 Middle School
19
I.S. 061 William A Morris445 CASTLETON AVENUE
  • 6–8 Middle School
20
Early College Charter School1441 South Avenue
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
21
South Richmond High School I.S./P.S. 256581 HYLAN BOULEVARD
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
Not rated
22
The David Marquis School of the Arts15 Fairfield Street
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
Not rated
23
Richmond Preparatory Charter School2245 Richmond Avenue
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
Not rated
24
P.S. R37391 HENDERSON AVENUE
  • Pre-K / 3-K
  • K–5 Elementary
  • 6–8 Middle School
Not rated
25
The Richard H. Hungerford School715 L Ocean Terrace
  • 6–8 Middle School
  • 9–12 High School
Not rated
How this is scored→
Browse all best-school lists →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best middle school in Staten Island?
Hellenic Classical Charter School - Staten Island ranks highest by our overall rating (83/100), ahead of I.S. 075 Frank D. Paulo. The best fit depends on your child — Smart Match (Motley Pro) ranks schools against your family's priorities.
How many middle schools are in Staten Island?
There are 26 middle schools in Staten Island.
How are these schools ranked?
By our overall rating — the average of the school's New York State ELA and math proficiency, grades 3–8, shown out of 100. The Approaching / Meeting / Exceeding bands are our thresholds, not New York State levels. Smart Match (Motley Pro) weighs academics, diversity, programs, distance from home, and special-education needs against your family's priorities.

Which of these fits your child?

Smart Match (Motley Pro) ranks the schools in your area against your family's priorities — academics, distance from home, diversity, programs, and special-education needs.

Find the right fit →